William Eichler 19 August 2024

Questions raised over Brum’s decision to issue s114

Questions raised over Brum’s decision to issue s114  image
Image: Juan Garcia Hinojosa / Shutterstock.com

An academic report has raised questions about the reliability of Birmingham City Council’s £760m equal pay liability figure and called for an investigation into the decision to issue a section 114.

The Audit Reform Lab (ARL), a collective of academics who investigate auditors, argue that the council’s financial problems were mostly the result of austerity and the ‘disastrous implementation’ of a new Oracle IT system.

The report, which was co-commissioned by the trade unions UNISON, Unite and GMB, claims that the decision to declare effective bankruptcy was initially attributed to a £760m equal pay liability which was ‘speculative and unaudited’.

Auditors Grant Thornton said the ARL’s report contained ‘inaccurate and misleading’ information.

The auditor said that it was inaccurate to attribute the council’s financial problems solely or even predominantly to the troubled roll out of Oracle, adding that service pressures and equal pay claims ‘play a greater part in the council’s financial issues.’

Referring to the £760m equal pay liability figure, Grant Thornton’s statement said: ‘Both officers and commissioners have confirmed that this is the best estimate available of the council’s liability on the available information.’ The statement added that the audit work is ‘ongoing’.

Responding to the auditor’s criticisms, Dr James Brackley from ARL said: ‘We circulated our report with all interested parties and took considerable care to ensure factual accuracy throughout the report. This included a lengthy discussion with Grant Thornton about our findings.

‘It is our view that the objections raised by Grant Thornton relate to points of interpretation not fact and we can see nothing in their comment to the press that contradicts any of the points made in our report.’

Check out: The financial crisis in Birmingham City Council.

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Activites Assistants (CASUAL)

Durham County Council
£24,404 (12.65 p.a. hour) - £25,183 (£13.05 p.a. hour)
This is an exciting opportunity for Casual Activities Assistants to join our Leisure and Sport Service.   Leisure Centres are
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Pension Administration Officer

Durham County Council
£24,404 to £25,183 p.a. (Grade 3) Pay award pending
A vacancy has arisen within Pension Services for an Administration Officer to provide admin and data support to the pensions team and members of the L Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

County Attendance Officer

Oxfordshire County Council
£37035 - £39513
We are seeking to recruit to the role of County Attendance Officer on a permanent basis to work predominately across the North or the South of the county. The team works across the whole of Oxfordshire so flexibility to work in other areas is also require County Hall, Oxford
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

Software Engineer Starter

West Northamptonshire Council
£26914
We're looking for an exceptional human to join our digital team to learn the skills and put them into practice, designing, developing and maintaining websites, mobile apps & AI. You'll join us on our journey as we create better end-to-end services for our Northampton
Recuriter: West Northamptonshire Council

Executive Director - Growth, Enterprise and Environment

Redcar & Cleveland Borough Council
£139,111.00 (pay award pending)
This is a chance to make a significant difference to the lives of families across our borough – and to seriously improve your quality of life. Redcar and Cleveland House, Kirkleatham Street, Redcar, TS10 1RT
Recuriter: Redcar & Cleveland Borough Council
Linkedin Banner