Alistair Kinley 25 August 2015

Vnuk: an involuntary risk transfer

Vnuk: an involuntary risk transfer image

We have seen the odd tabloid article telling Mr Smith that, because of the EU, he'll soon need to insure his ride-on lawnmower under a motor policy. However ludicrous that may sound, the reality is that could be true.

While newspapers have chosen lawnmowers and golf buggies as commonly used 'vehicles', what some have failed to uncover is how far reaching the implications of the European Court’s decision in Vnuk judgment really are.

On 13 August 2015 it was exactly eight years since a tractor knocked over the ladder on which Damijan Vnuk was standing while loading hay into the upper floor of a barn in rural Slovenia. He sued the tractor driver for compensation for his injuries. His claim ended up in the European Court last year.

As a result of this Europe-wide court case, the UK Government will very soon have to change the rules about motor insurance law and address accidents and risks that will, in future, have to be covered by compulsory motor insurance.

This imminent change will affect local authorities and their insurance arrangements, because some of the incidents currently covered under their employers’ liability (EL) and public liability (PL) insurance policies will have to switch over and be picked up by a motor policy. The current Road Traffic Act (RTA) will have to be amended in Parliament.

Incidents and vehicles caught

The law change is very likely to bring into scope a range of off-road vehicles and situations that would not previously have been included in motor policies, unless the Government makes a special exemption for specific types of vehicle when it consults on reform. We expect that to take place later this year.

Any vehicles used in off-road settings will now require insurance cover that complies with the RTA. This is where local authorities need to take particular note, as any vehicles you use in off-road settings will now require insurance cover that complies with the RTA. We’re talking about bringing vehicles such as ride-on lawnmowers, street cleaners, tractors, vehicles used to transport goods and products within depots, motorised wheelchairs and mobility scooters provided to local residents and even sit-on floor cleaners in use throughout your offices under the umbrella of your motor (fleet) policy.

Impact and timing

The changes outlined here will not take effect until the Road Traffic Act is amended in Parliament and will apply only for claims happening after that has been done. It is entirely possible that the Act could be altered in the first half of 2016.

A legislative response to Vnuk is needed, but discussion of the right thing to do will inevitably be polluted by the troubled nature of the UK’s relationship with the EU as a whole.

Predictably, the UK’s tabloid press has described the decision in Vnuk as 'bonkers' and 'insane'. It is neither. Instead, it should properly be seen as an incremental interpretation of the scope of compulsory insurance; a societal necessity recognised in the UK long before we joined the EU. What is crazy is the consequence that an F1 driver could end up having to be insured in the same way as a nervous learner driving a Ford Ka on a quiet suburban street.

The consultation which is expected start later in the year should be regarded as a great opportunity for local governments and other stakeholders to put forward constructive solutions. It’s about time to take your crash helmets off and put your thinking caps on.

Alistair Kinley is director of policy and government affairs at risk and insurance law business, BLM.

The Brownfield Land Release Fund image

The Brownfield Land Release Fund

To what extent does this early initiative of the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities deliver on the ‘levelling up’ agenda? Lawrence Turner reports.
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Planning Policy Manager

Royal Borough of Greenwich
£61.470 - £64.704
Be part of Greenwich's vision to successfully accommodate a high level of sustainable growth, which... Greenwich, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Refuse Driver (Rolling Advert - applications checked weekly)

Royal Borough of Greenwich
£30.032 - £31.610
It is an exciting time in Street Services at the Royal Borough of Greenwich. Be part of a team who are... Greenwich, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Commercial Contracts and Procurement Solicitor

North Yorkshire County Council
£32,910 to £43,857
Due to positive growth we are looking for Solicitors to join our Commercial Contracts and Procurements team. Homeworking
Recuriter: North Yorkshire County Council

General Legal Counsel – Corporate and Commercial

North Yorkshire County Council
£39,880 to £43,857
Are you looking for a legal career which is rewarding and offers the perfect blend of public and private sector working? Northallerton, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire County Council

Corporate Credit Control Officer

Camden London Borough Council
The post holder will act as the expert point of contact on all issues to instigate and conduct cases of appointee ship. Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Public Property

Latest issue - Public Property News

This issue of Public Property examines how how flexible workspaces can lead the way in regeneration for local authorities, Why local authority intervention is key to successful urban regeneration schemes and if the Government’s challenge of embracing beauty is an opportunity for communities.

The March issue also takes a closer look at Blackburn with Darwen Council's first digital health hub to help people gain control over health and care services.

Register for your free digital issue