William Eichler 12 December 2022

Ombudsman criticises Birmingham council of ‘maladministration’

Ombudsman criticises Birmingham council of ‘maladministration’  image
Image: I Wei Huang/Shutterstock.com.

Birmingham City Council has apologised for failing on multiple occasions to take action over a housing disrepair claim when prompted by the resident and the local MP.

The Housing Ombudsman made a severe maladministration finding against the council after the local authority failed to act on a complaint involving damp in multiple rooms and rotten floorboards.

In the Ombudsman’s investigation, it was not evident that the council had made a reasonable attempt to investigate or address the resident’s initial reports of repair issues.

Birmingham City Council also failed to arrange a further inspection as promised in its communication to the local MP who had been approached by the resident.

Richard Blakeway, Housing Ombudsman, said: ‘The number of failings in this case regarding poor communication, failing to provide services, and failing to follow up on promised actions would have caused significant distress for the resident.

‘Every landlord has a duty to meet its repair obligations. Should it leave repairs incomplete, it should have a clear and robust policy in order to make structured and reasoned decisions not to carry out repairs.

‘In this case, it is not evident that the landlord has any such policies, or that any risk assessment took place when it decided to withdraw its services and leave the works incomplete.’

The Ombudsman ordered the council to pay £1,050 in compensation and review current procedures for record keeping.

The finding comes as the Ombudsman is conducting a wider investigation into the council, due to be published early next year. The latest annual review into complaints also found a higher than average maladministration rate for Birmingham City Council at 54%.

‘This decision reflects a wider pattern of poor performance by the landlord. This includes a high level of failure when dealing with resident concerns and recent orders made by us to progress cases in line with our complaint standards,’ Mr Blakeway added.

A spokesperson for the council said: ‘Birmingham City Council has apologised to the resident for not repairing their property to an acceptable standard and has agreed to pay them the compensation outlined in the report.

‘As a result of this case lessons have been learnt and these have been passed on to the contractors who carry out our housing repair service. The other recommendations in the report will be acted upon and our contractors have been made aware of the findings.’

Skills Pipelines: What local government needs to know image

Skills Pipelines: What local government needs to know

Councils and mayors are to be handed a central role in developing skills pipelines for local industries, as the Government unveils what it calls a ‘fundamental change’ to the education system aimed at tackling youth unemployment. Here's what council leaders and officers need to know.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Head of Operations & Business Development - Amphora Colchester

Essex County Council
Up to £60000.0000 per annum
Head of Operations & Business Development - Amphora Colchester Colchester AmphoraSalary
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Technical Assistant

Essex County Council
Up to £25959.0000 per annum
Technical AssistantPermanent, Full Time£25,959 per annumLocation
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Assistant Director of Culture, Growth and Infrastructure

City of York Council
£86,537 – £95,898 plus benefits and relocation support
This is a new, pivotal and exciting opportunity for an inspiring leader to help shape York's future prosperity... West Offices York (minimum 3 days per week) / Hybrid working
Recuriter: City of York Council

Adults Social Worker - Early Help & Wellbeing (South Essex)

Essex County Council
£36124 - £51834 per annum + Flexible Working, Hybrid Working
This advert is open to Experienced and Newly Qualified Social Worker's (NQSW) with relevant experience in Mental Health. The starting salary for a NQ England, Essex, Basildon
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Part-Time Business Support Administrator

Essex County Council
£25959.00 - £28786.00 per annum + Full Time Equivalent
Part-Time Business Support AdministratorFixed Term, Part Time£25,959 - £28,786 Per Annum (Full Time Equivalent) Location
Recuriter: Essex County Council
Linkedin Banner