Austin Macauley 18 December 2014

Modernisation has caused ‘tribal’ mentality among councillors

A new study suggests there is a growing split among councillors, with backbenchers and cabinet members effectively becoming ‘two tribes’.

Based on a survey of 2,600 elected members, it reveals starkly contrasting views on the direction of local government.

Almost two-thirds of decision-making councillors believe the modernisation agenda for local authorities – which heralded the introduction of cabinet systems of governance – has been a success. Just 37% of backbench members agreed.

Two out of three non-executive councillors felt the changes had marginalised their role with 43% believing they could personally help to improve local services compared to 87% of executive elected members.

The Association for Public Service Excellence (APSE), which published the study, said the findings highlighted the need for local authorities to reconnect all councillors with decision making powers. One way to do that is through APSE’s ‘ensuring council’ model, which enhances the role of local politicians, said Paul O’Brien, chief executive of APSE.

‘Any dialogue on the future of local government needs to be grounded in a set of principles that genuinely advances local political leadership and democratic accountability,’ he said. ‘The ensuring council ethos offers a way of triggering that constructive dialogue.’

He added: ‘Councillors that exercise executive decision-making powers, or those in waiting to occupy such roles, expressed persistently different views from what we might term “backbench” members, regardless of political persuasion.

‘Party groups are a means whereby any potential divisions were mediated, but the poll raises questions as to whether the party group is up to the task of restraining the institutional drivers of the modernisation agenda.

‘This study shows there is a need to find a way to better recognise the contribution of councillors who may be focused on serving their communities but feel disconnected from decision-making.’

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Planning Policy and Place Manager

North Yorkshire Council
£53,051 - £57,372 per annum
As Planning Policy & Place Manager, working with a high degree of autonomy Northallerton, North Yorkshire - Hybrid
Recuriter: North Yorkshire Council

Neighbourhood Services - Assistant Director

Redcar & Cleveland Borough Council
£98,784 (plus hybrid working, removal/relocation package and excellent employee benefits)
You could be an experienced leader or this could be a step up for you. Redcar, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: Redcar & Cleveland Borough Council

Director of Education

Stoke-on-Trent City Council
£114,803 - £120,366
Our agreed local area SEND plan provides the basis for improving experiences and outcomes Stoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire
Recuriter: Stoke-on-Trent City Council

Executive Director of Education and Children’s Services

Lancashire County Council
Up to £180,000
Joining at a pivotal time, you’ll help shape Lancashire’s future as Devolution and Local Government Reorganisation Lancashire
Recuriter: Lancashire County Council

Executive Director – Children & Learning (DCS)

Southampton City Council
£170,000
Change lives in a city full of opportunity Southampton, Hampshire
Recuriter: Southampton City Council
Linkedin Banner