Laura Sharman 11 November 2015

MPs call for improved accountability on devolution deals

The Government has been warned its City Deals are not necessarily the 'most appropriate model' for wider devolution by the public spending watchdog.

In a new report, the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) warns that while the first wave of City Deals are showing early signs of success, a lack of monitoring and evaluation has made it difficult to assess their overall effectiveness.

'Devolving power and responsibilities carries the risk of weakened accountability,' said chair of the PAC, Meg Hillier. 'The fact that the Government cannot adequately explain where responsibility lies for the success or failure of City Deal programmes should therefore sound an alarm.

'It is also disappointing that there is no effective mechanism for comparing results in different cities, nor to scrutinise the knock-on effects projects in one area might have elsewhere.

'Taxpayers and indeed the Government are unable to assess precisely the impact of what has been delivered through the Deals so far.'

The report urges the Government to be clear about how it will determine the devolution of funding, and work with local areas to strengthen local scrutiny and accountability arrangements.

A DCLG Spokesman said: 'This "One Nation Government" is determined to rebalance our economy and ensure power and resources are devolved from Whitehall to local people who know best what is needed for their area.

'Ministers have been repeatedly clear that devolution of greater powers requires clear accountability, including through directly-elected mayors responsible to local taxpayers.

'The committee is right to recognise that City Deals were the start of a revolutionary new way of working – putting an end to decades of centralisation – and we will ensure lessons learned can inform future devolution deals.'

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Senior Project Manager (Regeneration)

West Yorkshire Combined Authority
£49,359 to £56,057 per annum (pay award pending) – Grade 9
With ambitious goals ahead, we need dedicated individuals who are ready to make a real impact as part of our expanding Housing team Leeds / Hybrid
Recuriter: West Yorkshire Combined Authority

Information Governance Officer

Essex County Council
£28349.00 - £33351.00 per annum + pension
Information Governance OfficerPermanent, Full Time£28,349 to £33,351 per annumLocation
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Information Governance Officer

Essex County Council
£28349.00 - £33351.00 per annum + pension
Information Governance OfficerFixed Term, Full Time£28,349 to £33,351 per annumLocation
Recuriter: Essex County Council

HR Advisor - Pay & Policy (Career Grade)

Wakefield Council
Grade 9 - Grade 10, Career Grade, 24 hours, Permanent
Are you ready to make a difference and shape policies that foster a high performing and inclusive workplace? Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Wakefield Council

Leisure Support Assistant

Wakefield Council
£12,013.50 - £12,202.00, Grade 3, 18.5 hours, Permanent
Are You Ready to Make a Difference in Your Community? Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Wakefield Council
Linkedin Banner