Dr Mark Brookes 03 August 2021

Democracy under threat: Elections Bill’s risk to people with additional needs

Democracy under threat: Elections Bill’s risk to people with additional needs image

Plans to require voters to show photo ID at polling stations have rightly received criticism in Parliament and further afield. Such a move would prevent thousands of adults in the UK from exercising their democratic right.

Dimensions’ Love Your Vote campaign, which aims to make our electoral process more accessible for people with learning disabilities, promoted the voting rights of people with additional needs ahead of the recent local elections. But the proposals contained in the Elections Bill would add, rather than remove, the obstacles to voting which people with learning disabilities already face.

Insisting that voters present ID ignores the experiences of people with learning disabilities, many of whom could be put off voting altogether by this added burden. Moreover, this would reverse much of the good work that has been done so far to make voting more accessible for people with additional needs, and we should be careful to protect these gains so that we can build on them.

Building up barriers

Making voter ID mandatory means excluding people who may find it difficult to obtain and/or use an ID, such as many people with learning disabilities.

While 91% of people in the UK carry some form of ID, the proportion is much lower among people with additional needs, such as those whom Dimensions supports. People with learning disabilities are less likely to have a passport or driver’s license, for example. Applying for other forms of ID, even (ironically) a blue badge, can be difficult for some and essentially impossible for others. Although no robust data exists, a small sample of the people Dimensions supports suggests between 20%-50% may currently have no ID.

As the bar to accessing paid support gets ever higher, people with ever more significant learning disabilities are having to survive independently. People – like me - in this position find it hard to manage our money, our health and our homes. We are highly likely to be digitally excluded. Recent data shows us suffering death rates from Covid-19 eight times higher than the general population in large part because information on how to stay safe simply isn’t accessible to us.

Government should be in no doubt that whatever the theoretical safeguards, this group – those in need of support but not in receipt of any - will inevitably be the most disenfranchised by any additional barrier blocking our path to voting. For some this will cause anger and distress. Many others will simply be silenced. Having seen how proud so many people with learning disabilities were to cast their vote in May, it is heart-breaking to think that we could soon be robbed of this experience – not to mention, of course, our democratic right.

If it ain’t broke...

Reducing the accessibility of voting for those with additional needs is even more shocking given that our electoral system has made good progress in recent years.

Having worked as an observer at my local polling stations last election day, I personally witnessed a very effective process in action. People were asked to provide their name and address, so there is already a system of identification in place.

Polling station staff were also incredibly helpful on the day, even explaining what would happen after the polls closed at 10pm. And throughout the process, security was extremely important. Indeed, voting is overwhelmingly secure in the UK.

So why risk effectively disenfranchising so many people with a so-called solution to a problem which we do not seem to have in the first place? Resources would be better spent elsewhere: improving the accessibility of the voter registration process, for instance, or promoting easy-read manifestoes more prominently. Such changes would improve the way voting works in the UK; forcing voters to produce photo ID at the polling station would not.

Democracy under threat

This attempt to introduce compulsory voter ID will not safeguard our democracy. Instead, it will leave it more vulnerable than ever, risking the rights of more than a million adults in the UK who have learning disabilities.

Our voting system is not perfect, but steps can be made to improve accessibility, and the last election showed the progress that had been made. Should the Elections Bill pass, however, we could follow this step forward by taking two highly damaging steps back.

Dr Mark Brookes MBE is advocacy lead at Dimensions

Meeting new planning requirements for trees image

Meeting new planning requirements for trees

Concrete block permeable paving offers an important opportunity to help satisfy the requirement for extensive tree planting and retention of existing trees in developments. Chris Hodson reports.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Senior Accountant x2

Islington London Borough Council
£39,462 - £45,594 per annum
There are two roles currently being advertised, one working with our Resources finance team, and one with our Housing and Public Health finance team. Islington, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Islington London Borough Council

Programme Director – Fisheries

Falkland Islands Government
£50,771 up to £56,292
The Programme Director – Fisheries will support the Director of Natural Resources Falkland Islands (FK)
Recuriter: Falkland Islands Government

Principal Engineer/Team Leader Street Works

Bath & North East Somerset Council
£39,880 - £42,821 pa
The Council’s Street Works Team is responsible for managing all aspects of road works and events that take place on our highway network. Keynsham, Bristol
Recuriter: Bath & North East Somerset Council

Social Worker / Advanced Practitioner – Children & Families Service

North Yorkshire County Council
£30,451 - £39,880 per annum pro rata + relocation support
North Yorkshire County Council have a national reputation for excellence. Skipton, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire County Council

Senior Technician - Asset Management - Highways & Flood Risk

West Berkshire Council
£23,541 to £29,577 per annum (Grade G)
We are currently looking to recruit to two exciting opportunities who will join us and play a role in improving West Berkshire’s highways. Newbury, Berkshire
Recuriter: West Berkshire Council

Public Property

Latest issue - Public Property News

This issue of Public Property examines how how flexible workspaces can lead the way in regeneration for local authorities, Why local authority intervention is key to successful urban regeneration schemes and if the Government’s challenge of embracing beauty is an opportunity for communities.

The March issue also takes a closer look at Blackburn with Darwen Council's first digital health hub to help people gain control over health and care services.

Register for your free digital issue