William Eichler 11 December 2019

Council loses court battle over £1m fatal bin lorry crash damages

Council loses court battle over £1m fatal bin lorry crash damages image

Glasgow City Council has failed in its bid to reclaim the £1m in damages it was forced to pay to the families of those who lost their lives in a bin lorry crash.

Six people were killed and 15 injured in 2014 when Harry Clarke lost consciousness behind the wheel of his bin lorry and crashed into shoppers in the city centre.

Glasgow CC’s insurers launched the court action against Mr Clarke's former employers First Glasgow, claiming that the bus company had offered a reference when he moved to the council and so it had a duty of care to the casualties.

Mr Clarke had ‘lost consciousness’ in 2010 while driving a bus for First Glasgow, the court heard.

The bus company, argued Glasgow CC’s insurers, should have known he was being dishonest when he changed his story about the fainting episode and they should have alerted the council when providing Mr Clarke with a reference.

First Glasgow disputed this claim and, in a written judgment, Judge Lord Ericht concluded that the bus company had no duty of care.

‘It is reasonably foreseeable that if a reference omits reference to a risk of the employee causing harm in the course of employment, then that harm may occur in the course of his work with the new employer,’ he wrote.

‘However ... foreseeability is not enough for the imposition of a duty of care. There requires to be a relationship of proximity. In my opinion in the current case there is no such proximity as would give rise to a duty of care.’

Lord Ericht found it would not be ‘just, fair and reasonable’ to impose this duty of care because it could have led to employers being no longer prepared to give references, as they could be held liable to ‘a great number of unknown persons’.

A spokesperson for the city council said: ‘This is a matter for our insurers. It would be inappropriate to comment further.’

Harry Clarke resigned from his job in November 2015 ahead of a disciplinary hearing.?

LGPS: Unlocking infrastructure image

LGPS: Unlocking infrastructure

Pension funds can play an important role backing useful projects such as railway infrastructure, water companies and green energy. Mark Whitehead met a man whose organisation invests local government pensions constructively.
Maximising tech spend image

Maximising tech spend

David Beggs calls on local government to take a much broader view of technology to get the most value from it.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Quality Improvement Officer

North Yorkshire County Council
£34,788.00 to £38,813.00
Would you like the opportunity to positively influence the quality of the social care market?   Northallerton, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire County Council

Housing Supply Manager

Redbridge London Borough Council
£48,492 - £51,450 per annum
We are seeking an individual looking to work in a resident-centred service that offers good quality accommodation options.  Redbridge, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Quality Assurance Contracting Officer - Northallerton

North Yorkshire County Council
£32,029.00 - £34,788.00 per annum, pro rata (Grade K)
This is an exciting opportunity to join an established team within the Health & Adult Services Directorate of North Yorkshire County Council.   Northallerton, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire County Council

Strategic Director Health and Wellbeing

City of Bradford MDC
£138,163 – £144,847
Bradford is changing at pace. Bradford, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: City of Bradford MDC

Pensions Officer

London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth
£25,327-£30,690 per annum
Looking for an enthusiastic and motivated individual to join our Pensions Shared Service as a Pensions Officer.  London (Greater)
Recuriter: London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth

Public Property

Latest issue - Public Property News

This issue of Public Property examines how public sector organisations can unlock the hidden value in their land, and why a new approach to construction could help boost the outcomes of the Government’s One Public Estate programme.

The December issue also considers why learnings from ancient cities could provide the key to promoting wellbeing in the modern built environment. It also contains a case study on how the London Borough of Westminster has provided high quality care for the elderly alongside a block of luxury apartments.

Register for your free digital issue