Jos Creese 16 January 2018

Carillion collapse: What next for public services?

The failure of Carillion raises many questions. The obvious ones are how it happened at all, since these sorts of collapses typically are long in the gestation, if anyone seeks the warning signs.

So, what were the government officials doing regarding due diligence and routine supplier monitoring as they invested taxpayer's money? Where were the auditors and why did they miss this (if they did)? Was it the range and reach of services across so many parts of the public sector that created a 'blind spot'? What lessons can be learned, especially in managing public/private service risks - and given the take payer usually has pay both ways when these sorts of failures impact public service delivery (look at PFI).

Allegedly, some of the smarter money apparently moved out of Carillion a while ago - if this is true, what did they know that others didn’t?

But there is a more serious question regarding the relationship between public and private sector in a digital age - protecting essential jobs and services as well as money.

In the wake of Carillion, many of the services and contracts provisioned by Carillion will be passed to others of run, at least for time. No doubt there will be costs of this, but at the same time, continuity and risk will be examined more closely, whether the services are delivered in-house of externally.

How can we determine the best model in the future, rather than trusting without apparent question old-style outsourcing contracts? Notably, many public service organisations are become more commercial, with successful shared service partnerships now spanning multiple public services. These are proving sustainable, and promise lower costs (marketing, salaries, profit, corporate overheads), greater flexibility/agility (not tied to contracts designed for a different age), greater resilience (or at least self-insurance) and ore transparency (democratic scrutiny and public-sector transparency).

It is also arguable they have a stronger public service ethos, with a greater commitment to service outcomes over shareholder value.

This is not an argument for insourcing or nationalisation. But it may be time to consider the service model that failed with Carillion and reassess the boundaries and expectations from public/private partnerships and a rebalancing of risk, cost and ownership.

Jos Creese is an independent digital analyst and consultant

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Home Job vacancies Speech and Language Therapist x2 Speech and Language Therapist x2

Isle of Wight Council
Grade 11, £45,668 to £48,662 per annum
This is not a traditional Speech and Language Therapy post. Rather than carrying a clinical caseload Newport, Isle of Wight
Recuriter: Isle of Wight Council

1

Isle of Wight Council
Hay Scale 3A, FTE £26,017 per annum pro-rata (actual salary £10,926.32)
The successful candidate will provide dedicated 1
Recuriter: Isle of Wight Council

Apprentice – Stores Assistant

Isle of Wight Council
National Minimum Wage for the age until completion of apprenticeship programme
We have an exciting opportunity for an individual who seeks an apprenticeship within a health and social care Newport, Isle of Wight
Recuriter: Isle of Wight Council

Mobile Cleansing Operative

North Yorkshire Council
£25,614 - £26,847
You will be part of a supportive team responsible for delivering a wide range of street cleansing Harrogate, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire Council

Mobile Cleansing Operative

North Yorkshire Council
£25,614 - £26,847
You will be part of a supportive team responsible for delivering a wide range of street cleansing and environmental services Harrogate, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire Council
Linkedin Banner