William Eichler 31 August 2023

Birmingham’s clean air zone less effective than previously thought

Birmingham’s clean air zone less effective than previously thought   image
Image: Edwin Ellis CreativeMedia / Shutterstock.com.

Birmingham’s clean air zone (CAZ) has been less effective at reducing the levels of nitrogen dioxide gas (NO2) than was previously thought, new research suggests.

It is normally claimed that the CAZ has reduced levels of NO2 pollution in Birmingham’s city centre by about 13%.

However, new research by scientists at the University of Birmingham has found that it has resulted in ‘modest, but significant’ reductions in NO2 of up to 7.3%.

The researchers used an innovative measuring technique that cuts out the impact on pollution of weather and seasonal effects.

The CAZ also has no detectable impact on the concentrations of fine particles, PM2.5 – the air pollutant with greatest health effects.

Professor Zongbo Shi, a senior author who oversaw the work, said: ‘PM2.5 at monitoring sites in Birmingham still regularly exceed WHO [World Health Organisation] air quality guideline levels, at which health impacts occur with significant health implications, including hundreds of premature deaths every year.

‘More rigorous policy interventions – such as further local measures to reduce wood burning and agricultural emissions and nationally co-ordinated actions to mitigate secondary PM2.5 pollution – are needed to address non-vehicle sources of PM2.5 as quickly as possible.’

A spokesperson for Birmingham City Council said: ‘What is clear from this modelling is that the introduction of the clean air zone led to an overall reduction in the levels of the air pollutant nitrogen dioxide. This modelling also supports our own analysis that the clean air zone has contributed to an overall reduction in the levels of nitrogen dioxide outside of the city centre.

‘However, since the period covered by this modelling, the overall percentage of the most polluting vehicles entering the clean air zone has continued to reduce and we expect there to be further reductions in the levels of nitrogen dioxide.’

If this article was of interest, then check out, 'Home County drivers face taxation without representation.' and 'Now I am become Uxbridge, destroyer of rational climate discourse'.

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Corporate Director Children and Young People’s Service

North Yorkshire Council
£136,853 to £159,178 plus relocation support
North Yorkshire is England's largest county and a beautiful, vibrant place to live and work. Northallerton, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire Council

Customer Service Assistant

Essex County Council
Up to £12541.00 per annum
Customer Service AssistantPermanent, Part Time£12,541 per annumLocation
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Executive Director of Communications and Engagement

City of London
Competitive Salary
This role requires strategic vision, operational excellence, and political acumen London (City of), London (Greater)
Recuriter: City of London

Support Worker

Oxfordshire County Council
£25992 - £28163
You will be supporting adults with learning disabilities, mental health needs, ageing needs and dementia. This is a frontline role where you will be providing high quality and meaningful activities, medication support, personal care, food and drink prepar Oxford
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

Community Support Worker

Essex County Council
£25395.0000 - £32131.0000 per annum
The Role As a Community Support Worker, your role will include undertaking Assessments and Reviews in line with our Statutory duties under the Care England, Essex, Clacton-On-Sea
Recuriter: Essex County Council
Linkedin Banner