William Eichler 11 May 2026

Voting system producing 'wildly unrepresentative' results, campaigners say

Voting system producing wildly unrepresentative results, campaigners say image
© Peter_Fleming / Shutterstock.com.

Last week’s council elections have thrown the distortions of the First Past the Post voting system into sharp relief, the Electoral Reform Society (ERS) argue.

In Sutton, the Liberal Democrats won 92.7% of council seats on just 43.7% of the vote, while Reform UK received only 3.6% of seats despite winning nearly a fifth of votes cast.

In Wandsworth, the Conservatives won more seats than Labour despite receiving fewer votes — what the ERS call a ‘wrong winner’ result. The Conservatives picked up 50% of the seats with just 29.9% of the vote, whereas Labour’s 32.1% of the vote translated into 48.3% of the seats.

Similar distortions were recorded in Havering, Hammersmith and Fulham, and Kensington and Chelsea, where large portions of voters — in some cases over a third — ended up with no representation on their council at all.

The ERS said the results demonstrate how a system designed for two-party politics is struggling to reflect an electorate now spreading its support across multiple parties, leaving thousands of votes making no difference to the final outcome.

Willie Sullivan, senior director of campaigns for the ERS, said: ‘This doesn’t need to be the case, and indeed it is not in large parts of the UK such as Scotland and Northern Ireland, where councillors are elected by proportional systems that mean council chambers far better reflect how people voted.

‘Thursday’s results underscore that it’s time to scrap First Past the Post in England and move to proportional voting so that councils properly represent the choices residents make at the ballot box.’

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Solicitor (Adult Services)

Cardiff Council
Grade 10 - £49,817 - £53,051
We are keen to recruit a high calibre, dynamic and qualified Solicitor/Barrister. Cardiff (Caerdydd)
Recuriter: Cardiff Council

Solicitor (Procurement)

Cardiff Council
Grade 10 - £49,817 - £53,051
We are keen to recruit a high calibre, dynamic and qualified Solicitor/Barrister.. Cardiff (Caerdydd)
Recuriter: Cardiff Council

Highways Officer

Derbyshire County Council
Grade 10 £36,591 - £40,008 per annum
Are you an experienced highways operative, supervisor, street works professional or traffic management specialist looking for your next challenge? Belper, Derbyshire
Recuriter: Derbyshire County Council

Social Worker

Durham County Council
Grade 9 (Pre-progression) - £36,581 - £40,444 / Grade 11 (Post-progression) - £42,123 - £46,579 pa.
Make a real difference when people need it most. Join a fast-paced hospital social work team where your expertise has a direct impact on patients and Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Contact Officer

Durham County Council
Grade 5 - £27,274 - £29,542 pa.
Help keep hospital social work services running smoothly for people across County Durham. If you enjoy working with people and keeping a busy team org Seaham
Recuriter: Durham County Council
Linkedin Banner