Paul Wheeler 13 September 2010

Soap Box

Nothing ever happens in August? Well, try telling that to the shell-shocked employees of the Audit Commission.

No-one loves a quango, but those celebrating the demise of the commission might do well to pause to see how some of its functions are carried out in the future. It is one of the great strengths of the public sector in England that we have avoided ‘Enron style’ scandals.

For local government, the Audit Commission has been there at some of the toughest times. Think about how the district auditor challenged the antics of rate capping councils in the 1980s, or the homes-for-votes scandal in the 1990s. Both episodes had the potential to damage the overall reputation of local government, and it took the commission to root out these problems.

In a more general way, the emphasis of corporate governance has ensured long-term improvement in councils such as Hackney, Hull and Walsall. Somehow, I doubt if short-term audit contracts with the big four accountancy firms will have the same consistency of approach and outcomes. I also pity the local government ombudsman. Apart from taking over the responsibilities for councillor conduct from the defunct Standards Board, it now has, in some ill-defined way, to respond to public concern on the performance of local councils. I am not sure if I would want to be manning its helpline in 12 months time. We should be wary of any extension of power for the National Audit Office. Giving more responsibility to an organisation directly accountable to MPs is hardly a success for localism.

But, for local government, there is a silver lining in the proposed abolition. In particular, there is a real opportunity for Local Government Improvement – IDeA, as was – to promote a rigorous form of peer review to provide an improvement framework for local councils – and other parts of the public sector. Peer reviews were a considerable success, and one which has not received the recognition it has merited in recent years. Local government will face enormous pressures in the near future. In particular, the army of ‘armchair auditors’ – the general public – will need robust, independent and consistent performance measures if we want an informed debate on service improvement and value for money.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Corporate Director Community Development

North Yorkshire Council
£145,894 to £169,693 plus relocation support
North Yorkshire Council is entering an exciting new phase of transformation, growth and opportunity. Northallerton, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire Council

Functional Family Therapy Practitioner

Cheshire East Council
£43,149 - £49,658
Do you want to be part of an innovative service that delivers evidence-based interventions and helps families thrive? Macclesfield, Cheshire
Recuriter: Cheshire East Council

Director of Adult Social Care

Nottingham City Council
£101,636 - £112,285 per annum (SLMG1)
As a key member of the Directorate Leadership Team, you will provide visible and effective leadership Nottinghamshire
Recuriter: Nottingham City Council

Director of Adults Service Development

Nottingham City Council
£101,636 - £112,285 per annum (SLMG 1)
This is a strategic improvement and assurance leadership role focused on driving the Adults Social Care improvement journey Nottingham, Nottinghamshire
Recuriter: Nottingham City Council

Adult Social Care and Commissioning Director Roles

Nottingham City Council
£101,636 - £112,285 per annum (SLMG 1)
This is an exciting time to join Nottingham City Council and help shape the future of Adult Social Care for the city.  Nottingham, Nottinghamshire
Recuriter: Nottingham City Council
Linkedin Banner