Ellie Ames 21 September 2023

‘Shockingly high’ justice system involvement among care-experienced children

‘Shockingly high’ justice system involvement among care-experienced children image
Image: sashafolly / shutterstock.com

A third of care-experienced children born from 1996-99 received a youth justice caution or conviction – a finding described as a ‘terrible indictment of the failure of local authorities’.

In the largest ever study of ethnicity, care experience and youth justice involvement in England, the experiences of almost 2.3 million children were monitored using new linked datasets from the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) and Department for Education (DfE).

The study of children aged 10-17 revealed that 33% of those with care experience received a youth justice caution or conviction, compared with 4% of those who had not been in care.

The figure is far higher than previous estimates and ‘a terrible indictment of the failure of local authorities to parent and support children in their care’, Care Leavers Association national director David Graham said.

The report states that ‘for a significant proportion of looked after children, the care experience does appear to contribute to the onset of offending behaviour, and for others it exacerbates and perpetuates their existing involvement’.

Care-experienced children from some minority ethnic groups were even more likely to have received a youth caution or conviction, including black Caribbean (39%), mixed white and black Caribbean (42%), Travellers of Irish heritage (46%) and Gypsy/Roma (50%).

Ethnic minority children in care face a ‘double whammy’ of disadvantage that increases their risk of youth justice involvement, the report states.

A statutory duty on local authorities to prevent unnecessary criminalisation of children in care and care leavers is recommended by the report’s authors.

They also recommended that the MoJ and DfE publish data using detailed ethnic categories where possible, and that better understanding across youth justice agencies of the needs of care-experienced children is promoted.

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Director of Public Health

Royal Borough of Greenwich
Up to £131,210
The Public Health department is at the heart of the council’s business. Greenwich, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Head of Regeneration and Growth

Plymouth City Council
£68,387 - £74,411 (MFS and relocation available, pay award pending)
This is a unique opportunity to lead our award-winning development team and directly deliver hundreds of millions of pounds of projects. Plymouth, Devon
Recuriter: Plymouth City Council

Director of Adult Social Care

Wiltshire Council
£119,390 - £127,137
Join us as the Director of Adult Social Care and make a real difference to people’s lives. Wiltshire
Recuriter: Wiltshire Council

Assistant Director Planning, Performance & Engagement

East Sussex County Council
up to £97,700
With strong local communities, unspoilt countryside and vibrant coastal towns, East Sussex offers an exceptional quality of life to many. East Sussex
Recuriter: East Sussex County Council

Director of Finance & Commerce

Lancashire County Council
Up to £114,339
You will play a critical role in driving the organisation through complex change and innovation. Lancashire
Recuriter: Lancashire County Council
Linkedin Banner