William Eichler 24 January 2019

School league tables ‘punish’ the wrong schools

Secondary school league tables ‘punish and reward the wrong schools’ by failing to take pupil background into account, new research suggests.

A study published today by the University of Bristol has revealed that a fifth of schools saw their national league table position change by over 500 places once factors such as pupil ethnicity, deprivation and special educational needs were taken into account.

Significantly, the study by Dr George Leckie and Professor Harvey Goldstein found that if the above factors were included in how the Government assesses school performance, 40% of schools currently judged to be 'underperforming' would no longer fall into this category.

The study was based on the 2016 data from all 3,098 state-maintained secondary schools in England.

It combined 'Progress 8', the headline measure used by the Department of Education to assess progress made by secondary school pupils, with information on pupil background — age, gender, ethnicity, whether pupils speak English as an additional language, special educational needs, free school meal eligibility and deprivation.

‘By factoring in vital information about a pupil’s background, we have seen a dramatic change in the league tables. This leads to very different interpretations and conclusions about education in England,’ said Dr Leckie.

‘It seems clear from our results that the higher the proportion of disadvantaged pupils in a school, the more it will effectively be punished for the national underperformance of these pupil groups. On the flip side, other schools are rewarded merely for teaching educationally advantaged intakes.’

Dr Leckie added: ‘The Department for Education's decision to ignore pupil background when comparing schools is in stark contrast to both the academic literature and feedback from teachers. At the moment, the simplistic nature of Progress 8 as a measure places too much emphasis on schools rather than the Government or society as a whole.’

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Adult Social Care Practitioner

Gloucestershire County Council
£34,237 - £37,563 per annum pro rata
We have a part time (4-day) Adult Social Care Practitioner position available in our Stroud Locality Team. Stroud, Gloucestershire
Recuriter: Gloucestershire County Council

Vocational Trainer - Maths

Essex County Council
Up to £34668.00 per annum + Pro Rata
Vocational Trainer - MathsPermanent, Part Time£34,668 per annum (full time equivalent)Location
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Coroners Officer

Isle of Wight Council
Grade 8, £31,859 to £34,812 per annum
The successful candidate will manage referrals from multiple agencies, maintain accurate case records, gather evidence Newport, Isle of Wight
Recuriter: Isle of Wight Council

Receptionist x3 (1 vacancy remaining)

Isle of Wight Council
Grade 3, £26,017 to £26,290 per annum pro-rata (actual salary £4,922.14 to £4,973.78)
Reception staff play a key role in delivering high standards of customer care Newport, Isle of Wight
Recuriter: Isle of Wight Council

Team Administrator

Isle of Wight Council
Grade 5, £27,274 to £27,710 per annum
Supporting social workers and managers with diary management, arranging appointments, meetings and visits. Newport, Isle of Wight
Recuriter: Isle of Wight Council
Linkedin Banner