Thomas Bridge 10 February 2015

Poll reveals questions over effectiveness of council scrutiny

Scrutiny of council decisions varies 'widely' across the country while opinion is 'divided' on local effectiveness, research suggests.

A study by Grant Thornton UK LLP found that while the average number of scrutiny committee meetings was 17, some local authorities only had one while another had as many as 66.

The All Aboard report found that while 90% of senior council officers, town halls, fire and rescue authorities and police bodies felt their organisation encouraged well managed risk taking and innovation, 43% of respondents thought scrutiny committees were failing to sufficiently challenge local authority practices.

While scrutiny committees were introduced 15 years ago to examine town hall decisions, almost one in five councils are thought to have returned - or were considering reverting to - a traditional committee structure.

Partner and head of local government at Grant Thornton UK LLP, Paul Dossett, said this 'could turn out to be a backwards step for effective scrutiny' as scrutiny committees 'can offer a valuable "check" to the executive'.

'Potentially, they can also offer a fresh perspective by taking both a long-term view of strategic issues and "deep dives" into vital areas of council operations. We know that some councils are doing this with great success so it's important that those who are struggling receive support to improve their processes so that they are not tempted to fall back in to outdated methods of scrutiny,' he added.

Some 84% of respondents said wider challenges facing councils meant their organisations were using or considering alternative delivery methods.

'Maintaining strong scrutiny over how local monies are spent is a principal tenet of good governance, providing assurance to council members and the wider public. Challenging why things are done and scrutinising processes and decisions encourages the development and introduction of more efficient and effective ideas,' Dossett added.

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Head of Housing

North West Leicestershire District Council
£64,241 to £74,525 (plus car allowance)
We are currently seeking a new Head of Housing to lead a number of key service areas Leicestershire
Recuriter: North West Leicestershire District Council

Director of People

Bolton Cares
£80,287 – subject to skills and experience
Bolton Cares is on an exciting journey of transformation and growth and we’re looking for a dynamic, people-focused leader to help shape our future. Bolton, Greater Manchester
Recuriter: Bolton Cares

Director of Finance (Strategy) – deputy S151

Nottingham City Council
up to £125k
Nottingham is a bold, vibrant, and exciting Core City at the heart of the UK, alive with potential and ambition. Nottingham, Nottinghamshire
Recuriter: Nottingham City Council

Adult Learning Tutor Maths WMF2142e

Westmorland and Furness Council
£35,235.00 - £36,124.00 (pro rata)
We are looking for an inspirational tutor to deliver maths courses to our learners across Carlisle. Carlisle, Cumbria
Recuriter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Adult Learning Tutor ESOL English WMF2144e

Westmorland and Furness Council
£35,235 - £36,124 (pro rata)
We are looking for an enthusiastic and self-motivated individual with experience of teaching ESOL. Whitehaven, Cumbria
Recuriter: Westmorland and Furness Council
Linkedin Banner