William Eichler 19 August 2016

National Living Wage should be ‘abandoned’, think-tank says

The planned move to the National Living Wage (NLW) should be ‘abandoned’, free-market think-tank says.

A new report by the Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA), entitled And how much do you earn?, argued there is ‘scant evidence’ that the NLW is an effective tool to alleviate poverty.

Criticising what it described as the politicisation of pay policies, the IEA also called for the National Minimum Wage to be simplified and for the scrapping of the planned publication of ‘crude’ league tables on gender pay gaps.

The think-tank cited the Office for Budget Responsibility’s (OBR) forecast that the NLW will lead to the loss of 60,000 jobs and the reduction of 4 million hours of work per week.

This suggests, the IEA claimed, that wage floors have a significant negative effect on employment levels. Any gains received in higher pay, they warned, must be weighed against job losses, and the loss of hours and benefits.

The report recommended Scotland be given devolved authority over its minimum wage and for the rest of the UK, the Low Pay Commission should have its authority restored to take in to consideration the impact of the minimum wage level on the labour market.

On the gender pay gap, the think-tank said there is no evidence to suggest that any differences between male and female pay can be attributed to employer discrimination.

They argued between the ages of 20-39 women's median earnings are now higher than men’s and that variations in pay represent different patterns of employment, different skills and different lifestyle choices and priorities.

Commenting on the report, author Ryan Bourne, head of public policy at the Institute of Economic Affairs, said: ‘Price controls in wage-setting have severe negative consequences. Regulations that try to influence wages in order to meet an arbitrary target will create perverse incentives in hiring and compensation decisions.

‘Sadly, rather than accepting that employers and employees come to agreements about pay according to specific job, pay policy is being driven by popular misconceptions, such as that pay levels are determined by discrimination, or that pay should compensate workers for their living costs.’

‘Where political views on pay are concerned, we have seen a regression to the meme,’ he added.

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Highways Inspector

Salford City Council
£30,515 - £32,578
Join us as a Highways Inspector in Salford to make the most of your knowledge of highways safety and legislation. Salford, Greater Manchester
Recuriter: Salford City Council

Planning and Highways Lawyer

Halton Borough Council
£48,738 - £51,928 plus a market supplement of £7k until December 2027
We're looking for an experienced and proactive Planning & Highways Lawyer to join our team. Reporting to the Principal Solicitor Halton, Runcorn
Recuriter: Halton Borough Council

Kinship Support Worker

Royal Borough of Greenwich
SO2 - £41,511 to £43,449
This is an excellent opportunity to become part of an experienced and skilled team working within a specialist area of Children's Services. London (Greater)
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Business Support Training Officer

Royal Borough of Greenwich
Scale 6 - £36,693 to £37,794
Lead on the planning, coordination and delivery of the foster carer training programme. London (Greater)
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

AARRC Practitioner

Royal Borough of Greenwich
Career Graded Scale 5 to SO1 - £33,609 to £40,575
You will be joining a genuine value driven Children’s Service’s directorate which is rated ‘Outstanding’ by Ofsted London (Greater)
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich
Linkedin Banner