Heather Jameson 31 March 2022

Levelling up plans will fail, IfG report claims

Levelling up plans will fail, IfG report claims image
Image: Number1411/Shutterstock.com.

The Government’s plans for levelling up will not cut regional inequality, a report from the influential Institute for Government (IfG) has claimed.

And plans to spread devolution deals across the whole UK are unrealistic and have failed to take account of the time and capacity needed to negotiate the deals, the think tank said.

Plans to rebalance the economy of the country also fail to reflect ‘the highly localised nature of regional inequality’, it stated.

According to the report: ‘Most of the missions are poorly calibrated because they do not set the right objectives, provide clear direction, or show the right level of ambition.’

The metrics behind Government’s objectives ‘miss out crucial aspects of the missions’, the IfG said, including local government funding, or simplifying fares on local public transport, while metrics on pay are branded as too regional by the think tank.

It claims only four of the missions are ‘clear, ambitious and have appropriate metrics’, while the other eight need to be rethought.

The IfG claims:

  • Five of the missions lack ambition
  • Three are too ambitions to be realistic
  • Four fail to define what success looks like
  • Two have too narrow a focus
  • One – on R&D spending – fails to line up with the overall policy objective

The report said: ‘The devolution mission states that every region of the UK that wants one should have a devolution deal with powers at or approaching the highest level of devolution by 2030.

‘Precedent shows that it takes time and resources to negotiate these deals, and the UK government has only limited capacity to do so.’

In its recommendations, the IfG called on the Government to:

  • Focus all the missions on broad outcomes that require multiple solutions
  • Clarify ambiguous concepts in the missions
  • Update the missions to make them appropriately ambitious
  • Measure progress at the local authority level, and set targets for high-performing areas to avoid ‘levelling down’
  • Provide appropriate resource for better sub-national data collection.
  • Set interim targets to track progress.
  • Make the Levelling Up Advisory Council a fully independent body
  • Give specific departments the lead on co-ordinating each mission.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Highways Officer

Derbyshire County Council
Grade 10 £36,591 - £40,008 per annum
Are you an experienced highways operative, supervisor, street works professional or traffic management specialist looking for your next challenge? Belper, Derbyshire
Recuriter: Derbyshire County Council

Social Worker

Durham County Council
Grade 9 (Pre-progression) - £36,581 - £40,444 / Grade 11 (Post-progression) - £42,123 - £46,579 pa.
Make a real difference when people need it most. Join a fast-paced hospital social work team where your expertise has a direct impact on patients and Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Contact Officer

Durham County Council
Grade 5 - £27,274 - £29,542 pa.
Help keep hospital social work services running smoothly for people across County Durham. If you enjoy working with people and keeping a busy team org Seaham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Cleaner

Durham County Council
£25,614 - 26,016 pro rata
Part time cleaner working 15 hours per week. 3.00pm to 6.00pm - Monday to Thursday 2.30pm to 5.30pm - Friday  Term time only plus 2 weeks to be worke Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Pastoral Mentor

Durham County Council
£33,673 - £37,563
Required to start as soon as possible.   Pastoral Mentor with Attendance Responsibilities The Mentor will be part of the team that is responsible for Ferryhill
Recuriter: Durham County Council
Linkedin Banner