Ellie Ames 20 June 2024

Landmark fossil fuel ruling has ‘profound’ implications for planning

Landmark fossil fuel ruling has ‘profound’ implications for planning image
Image: Balakate / Shutterstock.com

A historic legal judgement has ‘fundamentally changed’ the landscape around planning permission for fossil fuel extraction, campaigners have said.

The Supreme Court ruled today that Surrey County Council acted unlawfully when it granted permission for oil drilling at Horse Hill, near Horley, without considering the climate impacts of the inevitable burning of the oil.

Surrey’s environment impact assessment failed to consider the fact that more than 10m tonnes of carbon emissions would be produced when the extracted oil was burned.

While such ‘downstream’ emissions are increasingly omitted when planning authorities consider fossil fuel projects, the Supreme Court has now recognised that the damaging impact of emissions is not limited to where fossil fuels originate, according to law firm Leigh Day.

Sarah Finch, who challenged Surrey’s decision on behalf of the Weald Action Group, said: ‘The oil and gas companies may act like business-as-usual is still an option, but it will be very hard for planning authorities to permit new fossil fuel developments when their true climate impact is clear for all to see.’

The Weald Action Group said the ‘groundbreaking’ judgement could have ‘profound implications’ for planning decisions on new fossil fuel projects.

A host of previous decisions could also be impacted by the ruling, such as the permission granted for a new coal mine in Cumbria and development of the Rosebank oil field in the North Sea, according to Friends of the Earth.

A Surrey County Council spokesperson said: ‘Council officers at the time of the planning application assessment believed that they acted in compliance with the law.’

The local authority, which approved oil drilling at Horse Hill just months after declaring a climate emergency in 2019, said planning permission for the scheme would be determined ‘in due course’.

Black hole spending review image

Black hole spending review

Jonathan Werran, chief executive of Localis, reflects on what the Spending Review means for local government.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Family Support Worker

Durham County Council
Grade 6 £27,269 - £30,060
Are you passionate about Early Help and Prevention work? Do you want to work in an ambitious Local Authority with strong leadership and partnership c Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Residential Worker

Durham County Council
Grade 7 £29,093 - £32,654
Salary
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Team Leader

Durham County Council
Grade 8 £31,586 - £35,235
Salary
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Area Principal Educational Psychologist

Durham County Council
£65,432 - £69,399 Soulbury Scale B 8-11 (plus SPA points up to £73,412)
We are looking for an experienced Educational Psychologist with good interpersonal and communication skills who is ready to step up into a Senior Educ Spennymoor
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Enhanced Teaching Assistant

Durham County Council
£25,584 - £27,711 Pro-rata
Enhanced Teaching Assistant Grade 5   £25,584 - £27,711 Pro-rata Part Time 16.25hrs per week, Term Time only + 2 Weeks Permanent Required from 1.9.25 Newton Aycliffe
Recuriter: Durham County Council
Linkedin Banner