William Eichler 29 November 2023

Home Secretary acted ‘irrationally’ over National Transfer Scheme

Home Secretary acted ‘irrationally’ over National Transfer Scheme image
Image: Sean Aidan Calderbank / Shutterstock.com

The Home Secretary’s powers have been exercised ‘irrationally’ when it comes to the decision-making process in relation to the National Transfer Scheme (NTS), the High Court has ruled.

The use of hotels for unaccompanied asylum seeking (UAS) children was found in July to be unlawful after a claim of judicial review was brought against Kent County Council (CC) and the Home Office.

The High Court also found that Kent CC acted in breach of its Children Act 1989 duties by failing to accommodate and look after all unaccompanied children seeking asylum when notified of their arrival.

In a further judgement, the High Court yesterday ruled that the Home Secretary’s decision-making in relation to the NTS was ‘irrational’ because it failed to accept that the Home Office was partly responsible for Kent CC’s unlawful failure to discharge its duties to take UAS children into care.

The Home Office had also failed to take responsibility for the fact that the use of hotels had by December 2021 become systematic, routine and therefore unlawful.

Commenting on the judgement, Roger Gough, leader of Kent CC, said: ‘We are extremely pleased with the judgment handed down today proving that the long-standing issues we have had with the NTS remain unresolved and KCC was right to bring this Judicial Review.

‘For many years, Kent has been shouldering the responsibility of the nation in the care of UAS children and the judge recognised, as we have always said, that this is not a “Kent” problem but a national one, urgently in need of resolution by central government fairly and equitably across the nation.’

A Home Office spokesperson said: ‘The safety and welfare of unaccompanied asylum-seeking children and the provision of care placements for them is a national issue that requires participation from local authorities across the UK.

‘We are carefully considering the judgment today and will continue to work with local authorities across the UK to support them to fulfil their statutory duties to accommodate unaccompanied children nationwide.’

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Newly Qualified Social Worker - Family Support & Protection

Essex County Council
Up to £34902.0000 per annum
Newly Qualified Social Worker - Family Support & ProtectionPermanent, Full Time£34,902 per annumLocation
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Director of Finance and Section 151 Officer

East Cambridgeshire District Council
£84,607 to £107,153 per annum plus benefits
The Council is looking for a highly skilled and strategic Director of Finance and Section 151 Officer Cambridgeshire
Recuriter: East Cambridgeshire District Council

Senior Practitioner - Children & Young People with Disabilities

Essex County Council
£46574.0000 - £56027.0000 per annum
Senior Practitioner - Children and Young People with Disabilities, Mid EssexFixed Term, Full Time£46,574 to £56,027 per annumLocation
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Class Teacher

Durham County Council
£31,650 to £49,084 Pro-rata
Class Teacher M1- UPR3 £31,650 to £49,084 Pro-rata Permanent Part Time, Whole Time Required from 1st September 2025 Shotton Primary School is a happy Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Key Stage 1 Class Teacher

Durham County Council
£31,650-£43,607 pro rata
Key Stage 1 Class Teacher M1-6   £31,650-£43,607 pro rata Part Time, Whole Time, 0.4 FTE Temporary – required from 1st September 2025 until 31st Augus Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council
Linkedin Banner