Jonathan Werran 12 November 2014

Experts warn about 'flaw' in Barnett formula

Scotland has benefited from a £1bn funding boost because of the ‘flawed’ way in which civil servants applied the controversial Barnett funding formula to English business rates, public finance experts have calculated.

The finding is contained in a report issued today by renowned economists the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS), which has estimated the devolved Governments of Scotland and Northern Ireland were cushioned from spending review cutbacks to the tune of £600m and £200m respectively.

According to IFS economists, because the Treasury views English business rates as part-funding the Department for Communities and Local Government’s local government budget, most of the large spending review cutbacks imposed in England were not factored in when officials calculated block grants for Scotland and Northern Ireland.

As a result of this incorrect application of the Barnett formula, Holyrood and Stormont have seen their budgets cut by £600m and £200m less as a result of the 2010 and 2013 spending reviews, the IFS has estimated.

Additionally, the IFS economists noted Scotland benefited from £400m budget increases as a result of spending reviews during the 2000s than it would have were a corrected Barnett formula imposed, implying a £1bn unplanned funding boost – the equivalent of 3% of its 2015/16 budget.

Report author David Phillips, a senior research economist at the IFS, said because the leaders of the main political parties had pledged to maintain the Barnett formula, there was no likelihood of a shift to the sort of needs-based funding formula demanded by English council chiefs.

‘But it makes it more important than ever to examine the Barnett formula to see if it is working in the way intended, and if flaws are found, to fix them,’ Mr Phillips said.

He added: ‘It is important to get the interaction between devolved taxes and the Barnett formula right.’

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Senior Practitioner - Kinship Assessment Team Mid Essex

Essex County Council
£48205.0000 - £57988.0000 per annum
Senior Practitioner - Kinship Assessment Team Mid EssexPermanent, Full Time£48,205.00 to £57,988.00 Per Annum Location
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Ceremony Officer

Essex County Council
Up to £16.60 per hour
Ceremony OfficerFixed Term, Part Time£16.60 per hourLocation
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Director of Education

Stoke-on-Trent City Council
£114,803 - £120,366
Our agreed local area SEND plan provides the basis for improving experiences and outcomes Stoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire
Recuriter: Stoke-on-Trent City Council

Executive Director of Corporate Resources (Section 151 Officer) & Deputy Chief Executive

East Riding of Yorkshire Council
£153,685 - £164,743
This high-profile role combines the statutory responsibilities of the Section 151 Officer East Riding of Yorkshire
Recuriter: East Riding of Yorkshire Council

Highways Inspector

Salford City Council
£30,515 - £32,578
Join us as a Highways Inspector in Salford to make the most of your knowledge of highways safety and legislation. Salford, Greater Manchester
Recuriter: Salford City Council
Linkedin Banner