Jonathan Werran 10 October 2013

Doncaster ruling means councils can't force mayors to revise budgets, top judge finds

One of the country’s most senior judges has declared former Doncaster Mayor, Peter Davies’ victory in a legal battle over library closures, raises ‘important issues’ over the powers directly elected mayors hold over full councils.

In effect, the legal ruling makes it clear that full councils cannot order a directly-elected mayor to spend money in a particular way.

The comments were made yesterday in a High Court ruling, which found against resident, Carol Buck, who claimed Mr Davies, had illegally refused to put into effect a library funding budget amendment.

Court ruling The court ruling throws up issues around the division of power.

In March 2012 Doncaster councillors voted a £380,000 contingency budget to provide support to 14 community libraries. However, Mr Davies, who was defeated in this May’s local elections, refused to spend the money.

Lord Dyson, who is Master of the Rolls, the second most senior judge in England, said: ‘The claim raises important issues as to the division of powers between a directly elected executive and the full council of a local authority.’

‘The full council cannot require the mayor to expend money in a particular way’, added Lord Dyson, who sat with Lady Justice Gloster and Lord Justice McCombe in the appeal court.

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Social Work Consultant

Durham County Council
Grade 13 £48,738 - £53,051
Are you an experienced children and families social worker ready to progress your career and step into a management role?   Are you passionate about w Seaham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Family Group Conference Lifelong Links Co-ordinator

Durham County Council
Grade 9 £36,581 - £40,444
Are you passionate about empowering families, strengthening relationships, and helping children and young people build lifelong support networks? We Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Apprentice Business Administrator

Durham County Council
£15,434 per annum (£8.00ph) NMW
Earn. Learn. Qualify. Do you want to earn while you learn, with the chance of progression once you qualify? Do you want the opportunity to grow, deve Spennymoor
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Teaching Assistant

Durham County Council
£26,016 - £26,847 pro rata
Join Our Team at Oxhill Nursery School! Required for 33 hours per week, temporary from 1 January – 31 August 27 8
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Two Child Care Officers

Durham County Council
£29,071 - £32,046
Whole Time Required to start 4th January 2027   We have a vacancy for two Child Care Officers based across our 3 school sites. The posts are permanent Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council
Linkedin Banner