William Eichler 18 May 2023

Court clarifies council obligations under Human Rights Act

Court clarifies council obligations under Human Rights Act  image
Image: nampix/Shutterstock.com.

There is no requirement for children to be in the care of a local authority for the obligations under the Human Rights Act to arise, Court of Appeal rules.

The court considered the case of AB, a former looked after child, who claimed that Birmingham and Worcestershire councils failed to remove him from an abusive home environment. 

The local authorities had argued in the High Court that the Human Rights Act could not be used to bring this claim as AB was not already in their care.

The High Court concluded that the treatment AB endured in the care of his mother and known to the authorities was not serious enough to have breached his human rights.

The Court of Appeal upheld this ruling, but clarified that there is no requirement for children to already be placed in the care of a local authority for the obligations under Article 3 of the Human Rights Act—the article covering freedom from torture and inhuman or degrading treatment—to arise.

Anna Moore, partner at Leigh Day acting for AB in the appeal, said: ‘This case will have significance for many people like AB who, as children, should have been removed from abusive and neglectful environments, but the authorities responsible for their care did not step in to protect them.

‘The Court of Appeal has now unequivocally confirmed that the Human Rights Act can be used to bring claims in these circumstances. This means that others may seek redress when they have faced serious abuse and neglect and action was not taken to protect them.’

A spokesperson for Worcestershire County Council said: ‘We respect and acknowledge the ruling made by the Court of Appeal.’

Sign up here to recieve our free daily news and jobs bulletin.

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Strategic Director – Place-Based Services

Stevenage Borough Council
£Competitive
Stevenage is a town with bold ambitions. Stevenage, Hertfordshire / Hybrid
Recuriter: Stevenage Borough Council

Social Worker - Children's Assessment and Safeguarding

North East Lincolnshire Council
ASYE level £36,363 up to £46,142
Make the change, be the difference to our children, our future. North East Lincolnshire
Recuriter: North East Lincolnshire Council

Assist Response Officer

Mansfield District Council
£16,055.87 - £17,113.37 per annum (for 22.5 hours per week)
Mansfield District Council are looking for a dedicated individual to join our award winning ASSIST support scheme. Mansfield, Nottinghamshire
Recuriter: Mansfield District Council

Town Centre Operative

Mansfield District Council
£25,583 - £25,989 per annum
Working in local government is a rewarding experience Mansfield, Nottinghamshire
Recuriter: Mansfield District Council

Resettlement Officer

Ashfield District Council
£28,598 - £31,022 per annum
Would you like to work in our Housing Options Team helping people to settle in the local community? Sutton-In-Ashfield, Nottinghamshire
Recuriter: Ashfield District Council
Linkedin Banner