William Eichler 21 September 2022

Former looked-after child to appeal abuse case

Former looked-after child to appeal abuse case  image
Image: nampix/Shutterstock.com.

The Court of Appeal has agreed to hear an appeal in a case brought by a former looked-after child (“AB”) against Birmingham City Council and Worcestershire County Council.

AB, who suffered abuse and neglect while in the care of his mother, argues that he should have been removed from his mother’s care at an earlier date and by not doing so the councils contravened the Human Rights Act.

Worcestershire County Council provided AB with accommodation on several occasions in 2013. In May 2015, he was made the subject of an interim care order and a final care order was made in January 2016.

AB brought claims for breach of Article 3 [freedom from torture and inhuman or degrading treatment] and Article 6 [right to a fair hearing] of the European Convention on Human Rights.

However, the claim was struck out after a successful application by the local authorities.

The Deputy High Court judge ruled in favour of the councils, stating that ‘there is no realistic prospect of AB establishing there was a “real and immediate” risk of the ill treatment falling within the scope of Article 3. Nor is there a realistic prospect of establishing that the defendants knew or ought to have known of the existence of a “real and immediate” risk of Article 3 treatment.’

The judge also stated that the Article 6 claim did not disclose a legally recognisable claim.

AB applied for permission to appeal the decision to strike out the claim. He argued that the Judge had misapplied the test to determine whether a duty arises under Article 3 in looking at the facts of this case.

The court granted permission for the appeal to proceed and it will be listed for final hearing in 2023.

A spokesperson for Worcestershire County Council said: 'We do not comment on specific details of individual cases. We are aware that the Court of Appeal has given permission for an appeal for a decision involving Worcestershire County Council and we are unable to comment further at this stage of the judicial process.'

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Head of Democratic Services, Elections & Monitoring Officer

Harborough District Council
Grade 12 £67,236 – £71,223 plus £3000pa Statutory Officer Allowance
We are looking for an accomplished and proactive leader for our vacant post of Head of Democratic Services & Elections Market Harborough, Leicestershire
Recuriter: Harborough District Council

Social Worker

Durham County Council
£35,412 - £39,152 (pre-progression) / £40,777 - £45,091 (post-progression)
We are looking for social workers who have completed the assessed and supported year in employment to join our Families First teams, working with our Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Social Worker

Durham County Council
Grade 9 £35,412 - £39,152 (Pre-Progression) / Grade 11 £40,777 - £45,091 (Post-Progression)
Are you a nurturing social worker passionate about supporting parents so that children can remain with their birth family?     This could be the right Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Administrative Officer

Durham County Council
Grade 4 £25,583 - £26,824
An exciting opportunity has arisen for a Administrative Officer to join our busy, friendly team, supporting Children and Young People’s Services. 1 x Spennymoor
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Lunchtime Play Worker

Durham County Council
£24,796 pro rata
Lunchtime Play Worker Grade 1 £24,796 pro rata Part Time - 6.25 hour per week, Monday – Friday
Recuriter: Durham County Council
Linkedin Banner