William Eichler 22 August 2022

Councils encouraging ‘cut throat’ market in enforcement

Councils encouraging ‘cut throat’ market in enforcement  image
Image: eyematter / Shutterstock.com.

Nine in 10 councils who employ private enforcement companies to issue penalties for offences such as littering or loitering are incentivising the issuing of fines, new research has revealed.

A new report from the Manifesto Club, which will be published tomorrow, has found a ‘cut throat’ market in enforcement, with 10 private companies pitching for 'payment per fine' council enforcement contracts. This is up from five companies in 2018.

Defra guidance prohibits councils from using 'payment per fine' and other kinds of incentivised enforcement.

Sixty-six councils employ private enforcement companies to issue penalties for offences such as littering. According to the Manifesto Club’s findings, nearly 90% of them paid the company per fine, or used another system that incentivised the company to issue as many fines as possible.

The report found that enforcement contracts included estimated targets for penalties that would be issued and estimated ‘income targets’.

One company (Kingdom LA Support) made £659,077 from handing out penalties on behalf of Ealing Council. Merton Council made £702,632 from privately issued penalties.

The report includes two cases where councils tolerated significant mistakes by an enforcement company, continuing with the contract and judging it a ‘success’ because of the large numbers of penalties issued.

Boston Council contracted out enforcement for 17 different offences, while Hillingdon contracted out enforcement for 27 offences, including for Public Spaces Protection Orders (PSPOs), which include bans on standing in groups and on noisy remote control cars.

Private enforcement officers in Hillingdon issued 900 penalties for PSPO violations, and 331 penalties for obstruction of the highway. Enforcement officers in Greenwich issued 423 penalties for public drinking, 46 for loitering near a cash machine, and 161 for violating a Community Protection Notice (CPN).

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Housing Assurance Service Manager

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£55,675 - £56,649
We’re building a brand-new assurance team in our Homes & Neighbourhoods service Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Trainee Public Health Practitioner

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£24,404 - £24,790
Working within the Kirklees Public Health Improvement team Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Climate Change Officer

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£40,476 - £42,708
Are you a passionate and enthusiastic Climate Change Officer Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Transition Home Manager

Durham County Council
Grade 13 £45,718 - £49,764 (Pay Award Pending)
Could you support young people to realise their individual potential and prepare them for their journey towards independence. NOT JUST A PLACE OF WOR Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

SEND and Inclusion Senior Specialist Support Worker (Communication and Interaction Team)

Durham County Council
Grade 8 £31,586 - £35,235 (Pay Award Pending)
We are recruiting a SEND & Inclusion Senior Specialist Support Worker to join our Specialist SEND & Inclusion Team. We would be particularly intereste Spennymoor
Recuriter: Durham County Council
Linkedin Banner