William Eichler 14 November 2016

Council hits back at ‘damning’ Ofsted report

Council hits back at ‘damning’ Ofsted report image

Swindon council has hit back at claims children are being ‘failed’ after Ofsted published a damning open letter about ‘poor performance’ in the city’s schools.

The letter, written by the Ofsted regional director Bradley Simmons, said pupils in Swindon were being ‘failed at every level’.

‘Following the inspection of Swindon Borough Council’s arrangements for supporting school improvement and my letter to the leader of the council, I am writing to share my deepening concern over the poor performance of Swindon’s schools,’ wrote Mr Simmons.

This year’s phonics outcomes for Swindon are some of the poorest in the country, Mr Simmons said, with only 75% of 6 year olds meeting the expected standard. This places Swindon in the bottom 10 local authorities nationally.

At key stage 1, Swindon’s 7 year olds are the joint lowest performers in reading in the south west. This trend continues with only 44% of 11 year olds reaching the new expected standard in reading, writing and mathematics at key stage 2.

Ofsted also found at GCSE level only 17.3% of pupils, compared with 57% in England as a whole, achieved the English Baccalaureate.

Mr Simmons said he had raised these concerns to Swindon Borough Council on at least three separate occasions and found the council to be ‘defensive in its response.’

‘Pupils in Swindon are being failed at every level,’ Mr Simmons warned.

‘Primary school performance which had previously shown a positive trend of improvement in Swindon, is now a concern.’

‘If Swindon’s pupils are to have the skills and qualifications required to improve their life chances everyone with a responsibility for education needs to take immediate action,’ he concluded.

However, the council said it was ‘very surprised’ to receive the letter.

It pointed out that, according to Ofsted’s own assessment, 98% of early years settings in Swindon are good or outstanding, and 92% of Swindon primary schools are good or outstanding - above the national average.

Swindon council acknowledged the standard of education in their area needed improving, but they said they had been working on it and they were surprised to learn of Mr Simmons’ criticisms.

'Ofsted inspectors from the South West ran school improvement training sessions for headteachers and governors in July and the Council, in partnership with Ofsted, arranged a follow-up session in September,’ the council said

‘All the work we have undertaken has been with Ofsted’s full knowledge and we believed we had its full support.’

Furthermore, the council criticised Mr Simmons for publishing his open letter.

‘By making his views so public in this way, Mr Simmons must have recognised the demotivating impact they would have on teachers,’ they said.

‘In fact it has really angered and annoyed many headteachers of good and outstanding schools who are doing an excellent job providing high class education for children and young people whether they are in council maintained schools or academies.’

Supporting the most vulnerable in Herts image

Supporting the most vulnerable in Herts

Hertfordshire CC is investing £9.6m to support its most vulnerable residents in overcoming the repercussions of the pandemic. Scott Crudgington explains why the council is determined to remain ‘a county of opportunity’ for all.
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

People Technology / HRIS Analyst

Essex County Council
Up to £42174 per annum
The Opportunity The People Technology / HRIS Analyst will be responsible for supporting the ongoing management of people-based technology including England, Essex, Chelmsford
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Principal Energy Engineer

Surrey County Council
£45,734 - £51,725 per annum
Do you have experience in working with delivering carbon reduction measures into a range of building projects? Surrey
Recuriter: Surrey County Council

Wellbeing and Independence Practitioner - Safeguarding

Essex County Council
£27203 - £31370 per annum
Please note, this role is a Fixed Term Contract until the end of March 2022. With us, you can achieve more - for yourself as well as those you work England, Essex, Chelmsford
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Chief Fire Officer/Chief Executive

Essex County Fire & Rescue Service
c. £150,000
Are you ready for an exciting and rewarding opportunity Essex
Recuriter: Essex County Fire & Rescue Service

Housing Development Manager

City of York Council
£36,476 to £41,830 per annum
Do you want to play a key part in the delivery of “the UK’s most ambitious council-led housing programme in a generation”? York, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: City of York Council

Public Property

Latest issue - Public Property News

This issue of Public Property examines how how flexible workspaces can lead the way in regeneration for local authorities, Why local authority intervention is key to successful urban regeneration schemes and if the Government’s challenge of embracing beauty is an opportunity for communities.

The March issue also takes a closer look at Blackburn with Darwen Council's first digital health hub to help people gain control over health and care services.

Register for your free digital issue