Tim Young 30 September 2020

The pressure of procurement

We, like many other consultancies, have seen a huge rise in the number of tenders that have been issued by local authorities during the COVID lockdown period. With this also comes an increasing tendency for local authorities to procure consultant teams for new-build housing under a consortium led by the project manager.

However, this approach is restricting competition and has led to many small and medium-sized consultants missing out on contracts due to the way the tender process is being conducted. For the local authorities, it reduces the likelihood that they’ll get access to the best experience and advice across all aspects of their building project.

It’s understandable, of course, that local authorities are looking to simplify their procurement processes, but requiring a consultant to provide a fixed fee on an estate regeneration, particularly when the extent of the works is unknown, is unlikely to provide positive results.

The current market is tightening so that only a limited number of the very large global PM consultancies are able to take on a full design team as sub-contractors to deliver new build housing, and I feel it’s unlikely they’ll truly have all the depth of expertise that’s needed to give the local authorities best value and quality.

What’s the solution?

We believe there is a better model, which sees a single project manager lead, picking up cost manager, principle designer and site inspector roles, but with a separate design team, usually led by an architect, and bringing in other design consultants as sub-contractors. This has the added benefit of providing a continuous separate, independent review of the evolving design process. The client is then getting better value for money and a surer chance of success.

Go back to the shortlist

Typically, local authorities will look to their procurement framework agreements and issue tender invitations accordingly. But lately the current default position seems to be not only to want just one company to deliver everything, but to ask all companies on the frameworks to bid, regardless of whether they really have all the expertise that’s needed.

This is very costly for companies to respond to tenders, and frankly unrealistic to ask twenty companies to bid. It would be better – as advised in the OJEU rules – to have a filtering process in place so you can screen out the outliers and focus on say three or four companies.

Utilise expertise

We believe that it makes good business sense for local authorities to make sure that they have SME’s on their frameworks, or on approved supplier lists. This means they can drill down and look at what their project needs, and identify the specialist companies on their databases who are best placed to ensure success.

For example, we recently worked on a local authority housing project where the anticipated number of homes was 70. As the scheme evolved, the specialist SMEs involved were able to work together to identify hidden opportunities and expand this project to 180 units.

If the project had been delivered under the local authority large consultancy approach, it is unlikely the same incentive would have existed to encourage such a radical scheme design change. By drawing on multiple SMEs each with their individual areas of expertise, the local authority was able to remain flexible and deliver quite a different scheme to that which was originally envisaged. This was a great result for the local authority and more importantly this approach has helped to provide much needed additional homes for the local community.

Tim Young is equity partner and head of innovation at John Rowan and Partners

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Director of Public Health

Royal Borough of Greenwich
Up to £131,210
The Public Health department is at the heart of the council’s business. Greenwich, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Head of Regeneration and Growth

Plymouth City Council
£68,387 - £74,411 (MFS and relocation available, pay award pending)
This is a unique opportunity to lead our award-winning development team and directly deliver hundreds of millions of pounds of projects. Plymouth, Devon
Recuriter: Plymouth City Council

Director of Adult Social Care

Wiltshire Council
£119,390 - £127,137
Join us as the Director of Adult Social Care and make a real difference to people’s lives. Wiltshire
Recuriter: Wiltshire Council

Assistant Director Planning, Performance & Engagement

East Sussex County Council
up to £97,700
With strong local communities, unspoilt countryside and vibrant coastal towns, East Sussex offers an exceptional quality of life to many. East Sussex
Recuriter: East Sussex County Council

Director of Finance & Commerce

Lancashire County Council
Up to £114,339
You will play a critical role in driving the organisation through complex change and innovation. Lancashire
Recuriter: Lancashire County Council
Linkedin Banner