William Eichler 08 November 2018

Social work failings stopped parents visiting dying baby

A council has apologised for the ‘distress’ of a family who were unable to spend time with their dying baby due to social work failings.

City of York Council has apologised after being found at fault by the local Government and Social Care Ombudsman for not providing appropriate supervision for the parents of a child in its care in hospital.

The Ombudsman also criticised the council for not responding to the parents’ complaints quickly enough.

The parents took the baby, who had a range of health conditions, to hospital with breathing difficulties where the doctor treating him noticed injuries to his ribs.

The parents argued these could have been caused by previous hospital treatment, but an intervention by the council led to their two other children being placed in the care of their grandparents.

Social workers also had to supervise the parents when they visited the hospital where their son was staying.

These restrictions meant some days the parents could only spend four hours with their son. On one day a lack of supervision meant they were not able to visit him at all.

The baby died nine weeks after his admission to hospital.

A court hearing later led to the council’s handling of the case being criticised. It found the council had decided the fractures ‘cannot have been attributed to parental care’.

An investigation by the Ombudsman found the council should have reviewed the supervision arrangements or offered third party services to provide supervision in hospital. It also failed to visit the baby in hospital and the care plan drawn up did not consider the baby’s emotional needs.

‘Nobody could criticise the social workers in this case for starting the safeguarding action,’ said Ombudsman Michael King.

‘But what they should have done was keep the situation under review, especially once it became clear there was very little risk to the child, and his condition deteriorated.

‘This would have been a horrifically stressful time for the family, at a time when their world must have felt like it was falling apart.

‘Social workers should have done more to facilitate the parents’ visits, for example by contacting social workers in the neighbouring authority, or the hospital’s own patient liaison services.’

Ombudsman King also noted the council took ‘far too long’ to investigate the parents concerns when they complained about their treatment.

Maxine Squire, interim corporate director for children, education and communities, City of York Council, said: ‘We are extremely sorry for the distress caused and have apologised unreservedly to the family.

‘We fully accept the Ombudsman’s findings and recommendations. We have already taken action to ensure that lessons are learnt from this case and that our procedures are improved.’

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Senior Product Support Analyst

Essex County Council
£33512 - £39425 per annum + Hybrid Working
*Experience the best of both worlds with our flexible hybrid working arrangements. Enjoy the freedom to work from home while still benefiting from in England, Essex, Chelmsford
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Security Architect

Essex County Council
£60049 - £70645 per annum + Hybrid Working
This is a 12 month fixed term contract or secondment opportunity.*Experience the best of both worlds with our flexible hybrid working arrangements. E England, Essex, Chelmsford
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Control Officer

London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth
£37602 - £45564 plus shift and weekend allowance
Are you looking for your next opportunity to work as part of a team in a 24-hour emergency control room covering the Boroughs of Richmond and Wandsworth. To be responsible for receiving and logging calls from the public, outside agencies and partners. Use Wandsworth, London
Recuriter: London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth

Senior User Centered Designer

Essex County Council
£60049 - £70645 per annum + Hybrid Working
Interviews will be held on 29th and 30th October 2025.*Experience the best of both worlds with our flexible hybrid working arrangements. Enjoy the fr England, Essex, Chelmsford
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Network and Communications Lead

Essex County Council
£52621 - £61906 per annum + Hybrid working
Interviews will be held W/C 20th October 2025.*Experience the best of both worlds with our flexible hybrid working arrangements. Enjoy the freedom to England, Essex, Chelmsford
Recuriter: Essex County Council
Linkedin Banner