The case for a centrally controlled, or at least regulated, public procurement strategy has strengthened in recent weeks.
First the NHS was revealed to have had issues with some groups paying more than their peers in different areas for the same products. This was replicated days later with the revelation that the same situation existed within the police department with the price to different forces for the same stand-issue boots ranging from £25 to £114.
Most recently, we have seen the vast difference the UK’s police are paying for their X26 taser guns (£850) compared to the price paid in the US for the same device (£547).
Keeping track of your suppliers and your procurement spending is a key requirement of all businesses, whether a sole trader on a low income or a public authority. A large part of that tracking is ensuring you are getting the best deal possible for your business so you are fully utilising your capital resources. This was clearly not being done as far as the police and NHS were concerned
In the case of the NHS, recent research has shown that the most important resource available in healthcare, a doctor’s time, is not being used properly. It was reported that 'attending management meetings and doing administration takes up around 17 hours a week, compared to seven hours spent at patients' bedsides'. While this is bad enough from the point of view of service delivery, what is most worrisome is the quality of the decisions being made during these hours of administration.
A recent article by Dr. David Zigmond on his experiences of attending a meeting for a Clinical Commissioning Group casts a questioning light on the practice of decentralising procurement and supplier decisions to those who have neither the time, expertise, nor, crucially, the experience to deliver quality work in the area.
Far from describing a smoothly run system that puts power into the hands of local groups, Dr. Zigmond reports on the 'bodily presence but mental absence' of his colleagues when at a meeting on procurement.
Similar fears exist over a potential decline in service levels within the police. There have been cuts in staff levels and recruitment, pay is being severely affected and overall funding is a real concern.
Recently we saw the impact poor procurement processes were having on the service’s expenditure with wildly varying prices being paid for identical items, an issue that would not have arisen had the procurement for the police force been handled centrally, or at least with proper communication between the different procurement groups.
This all leads to the important question: should the police or the NHS rely on a centralised purchasing function or should procurement be handled by individual teams? The argument for centralised procurement is that greater purchasing volumes enable economies of scale, but the other side of the coin is reduced autonomy at a local level over purchasing decisions.
Police procurement will be affected by the European Commission’s mandate that all public sector bodies must implement e-procurement platforms by 2016 to reduce cost and improve efficiency and transparency, and this measure will go a long way towards correcting the types of problems we see with public procurement today.
For both the NHS and the police, if a localised approach is preferred then turning to e-procurement could also deliver some of the traditional advantages of a centralised process such as lower cost, greater efficiency and transparency, and improved spend analysis, whilst keeping the flexibility and autonomy that enables local bodies to make purchases without being dictated to by a central unit.
Pedro Paulo is CEO of Gatewit.