Ellie Ames 22 February 2024

Planning inspectors acted unlawfully over council’s net zero plans

Planning inspectors acted unlawfully over council’s net zero plans image
Image: West Oxfordshire District Council

Planning inspectors were wrong to describe West Oxfordshire District Council’s net zero plans for a garden village as ‘too rigorous’, a High Court judge has ruled.

The local authority said Salt Cross Garden Village, which is to be built between Witney and Oxford, should be fossil fuel free, with 100% of the energy required by its buildings generated from onsite renewables.

But inspectors said the council’s standards for the scheme conflicted with a 2015 written ministerial statement that set out national policy on energy efficiency.

After climate collective Rights Community Action (RCA) launched a legal challenge, Mrs Justice Lieven ruled this week that planning inspectors had acted unlawfully when they said the village did not need to be built to the council’s net zero standards.

She said inspectors were wrong to take the 2015 ministerial statement as an expression of national policy without recognising later law and policy.

Leigh Day solicitor Ricardo Gama, who represented RCA, said: ‘The case is a frustrating example of a local authority trying to take ambitious action on climate change and being hamstrung by confusion in central government and so it’s welcome that the judge has clarified the legal position.’

Council leader Andy Graham said the authority was ‘incredibly pleased’ with the judgement.

He added: ‘We want this to be a groundbreaking, sustainable housing development which is why we pushed for higher standards in regards to net zero carbon homes and energy efficiency.’

The Planning Inspectorate declined to comment.

Making payment processes smarter  image

Making payment processes smarter

It can be challenging to find the right software to streamline payment processes. Lewis McKenna-Crisp argues SmarterPay has the ideal solution for councils.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Director of Public Health

Royal Borough of Greenwich
Up to £131,210
The Public Health department is at the heart of the council’s business. Greenwich, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Head of Regeneration and Growth

Plymouth City Council
£68,387 - £74,411 (MFS and relocation available, pay award pending)
This is a unique opportunity to lead our award-winning development team and directly deliver hundreds of millions of pounds of projects. Plymouth, Devon
Recuriter: Plymouth City Council

Director of Adult Social Care

Wiltshire Council
£119,390 - £127,137
Join us as the Director of Adult Social Care and make a real difference to people’s lives. Wiltshire
Recuriter: Wiltshire Council

Assistant Director Planning, Performance & Engagement

East Sussex County Council
up to £97,700
With strong local communities, unspoilt countryside and vibrant coastal towns, East Sussex offers an exceptional quality of life to many. East Sussex
Recuriter: East Sussex County Council

Director of Finance & Commerce

Lancashire County Council
Up to £114,339
You will play a critical role in driving the organisation through complex change and innovation. Lancashire
Recuriter: Lancashire County Council
Linkedin Banner