Jonathan Werran 19 August 2011

PFI addiction must end, MPs urge

Whitehall's addiction to off-balance PFI schemes to fund capital projects must end, an influential cross-party committee has urged.

A critical report issued by the Treasury Select Committee argues 'perverse incentives' and a biased value for money appraisal system - encouraging public bodies to commit to major long-term investments without large up-front costs - are now 'extremely inefficient' in a post-credit crunch era of higher borrowing costs.

The committee recommends investment could be increased in the long time if government capital investment were used instead. Analysis undertaken for the report suggests it costs £1.7bn to pay down a PFI debt worth £1bn and capital costs for even low-risk PFI projects are over 8%, double that of government gilts.

Identifying a number of problems with how costs and benefits are assessed in PFI projects, the MPs claim not to have seen any convincing proof that savings and efficiencies offset the 'significantly higher cost of finance'. They call for the greatest amount of risk to be visibly transferred to the private sector.

Chairman of the Treasury Select Committee, Andrew Tryie MP said: 'PFI means getting something now and paying later. Any Whitehall department could be excused for becoming addicted to that.'

A key recommendation of the committee is that independent government spending watchdog, the Office for Budget Responsibility, should include PFI liabilities in future assessments of fiscal rules.

Last month the OBR's first whole of government accounts (WGA) indicated local authorities' share of such liabilities comes to just under half of the £69bn total, with 226 out of a total of 609 cross-government PFI deals worth £33.3bn. On 29 July education secretary Michael Gove launched a £2bn funding scheme for school buildings across England.

Dr Neil Bentley, deputy director-general at the CBI said PFI must only be used when it offers the best value for money.

'But with the state of the public finances, it is absolutely essential we attract the billions of pounds of private finance needed to upgrade our national infrastructure and boost jobs and growth.

'To do this, investors need confidence, and the government must decide sooner rather than later how PFI will evolve, alongside a range of alternatives, such as Tax Increment Funding (TIF) and pension fund financing,' he said.

UNISON General Secretary, Davie Prentis commented: 'Government incentives and short-term gain are being put before the long-term pain.

'PFI is a huge burden on the public sector and has cost taxpayers billions over the odds. The huge PFI debts hospitals have run up have played a major part in the cuts being made to staff and treatments.'

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Adults Social Worker - West Essex (Expression of Interest)

Essex County Council
£36124 - £51834 per annum + Flexible Working, Hybrid
Register your interest here to be notified of upcoming Social Worker opportunities within Essex County Council's Adult Social Care services in West E England, Essex, Harlow
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Director of Education

Nottingham City Council
£109,702 - £113,977 (Soulbury Grade 47 – 50)
We are now seeking visionary senior leaders to help shape the next phase of Nottingham's improvement journey. Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, Hybrid
Recuriter: Nottingham City Council

Senior Network Asset Inspector

Barnet London Borough Council
Salary range Grade J
Barnet London Borough Council
Recuriter: Barnet London Borough Council

Team Around the Family Worker

Nottinghamshire County Council
Starting Salary is £37,563 (Level one) rising to £40,444 (Level four) per annum (pro rata for part-time)
To work collaboratively with partners agencies to promote, implement, and embed the Team around the Family (TAF) Nottingham, Nottinghamshire
Recuriter: Nottinghamshire County Council

Occupational Therapy Assistant

Nottingham City Council
Starting Salary is £33,673 (Level one) rising to £36,581 (Level four) per annum (pro rata for part-time)
We're looking for a motivated and compassionate Occupational Therapy Assistant. NG11 8EW, Nottingham
Recuriter: Nottingham City Council
Linkedin Banner