Allison Whittington 12 March 2018

MMC: Knowing the risks

MMC: Knowing the risks image

The UK’s housing infrastructure delivery has been under pressure for a number of years and the government needs a solution to achieve its targets at nearly double current rates.

Innovative solutions, such as using modern methods of construction (MMC) can provide a range of benefits, and are particularly attractive to the social housing sector and local authorities looking to construct public buildings in the most efficient manner.

We understand that new projects are increasingly looking to such methods to contribute to the volume of housing needed and meet the latest standards on sustainability and environmental performance.

Some popular MMC solutions can, however, introduce added risks, both during construction and throughout a building’s lifespan and there is a lack of understanding of the risks associated with properties built in this manner.

Timber-framed buildings

The insurance risks around MMC building techniques often relate to timber frames after fires have occurred both during and after construction. This building technique now accounts for around 25% of new homes built in the UK, according to the Structural Timber Association. Consequently, the STA has introduced a number of fire safety initiatives in order to improve performance of such builds.

Therefore, fire protection measures must be a priority in design and construction phases for all timber-framed structures. High quality of construction and contractor awareness are essential to ensure measures such as correctly specified and installed fire stopping are provided.

Modular construction

Off-site construction is a growing trend in the UK and now accounts for around 12% of all projects. One method, that of volumetric or modular construction, allows for factory-produced units to be placed straight on to prepared foundations, which in many cases reduces overall construction contract periods. However, the ability of some MMC materials to withstand the effects of flooding or water damage may be unproven.

In addition, some problems with such constructions may only become apparent years after completion, for example if the lower sections of the units were damaged or incorrectly specified during assembly and the structure is subsequently subject to flooding.

Pre-fabricated units may not be able to be repaired in situ and, dependant on the design of the specific system, may need to be removed and replaced. Such measures would clearly cause disruption to and removal of the surrounding pods or units and external finishes increasing reinstatement costs in comparison to more traditional build.

Similarly, where component parts are fixed together – notably modules and pods – there may well be hidden voids through which smoke, hot gases and water can permeate throughout a building, leading to even a small incident causing a disproportionately high loss.

Dangers of new technology

Some MMC, by their very nature, are new and innovative. For this reason alone, contractors may have little or no previous experience of the materials, systems and assembly techniques required. This again could lead to additional risks, particularly in relation to fires if contractors are unaware of hidden combustible insulation, than if more traditional methods had been used. There could also be problems in obtaining replacement components in the future.

Excellent contractor and management selection is, therefore, essential in order to ensure a full understanding of the MMC techniques being utilised, their likely performance including life cycle requirements, and how resilient they are to changes and adaptions throughout the life of the building.

Question marks, too, have been raised over the fire performance of some of the insulation products and materials used both within building structures, and on the external faces of buildings of both new and existing buildings, whereby their combustibility can significantly increase fire risks.

The overall fire performance must be carefully considered when using MMC – including weighing up the combined properties of materials – with a need for ‘joined-up’ thinking throughout the design, build and maintenance process to ensure that the true risks are recognised and fully understood by all stakeholders.

Risks associated with MMC are not easy to assess, however. That is why at Zurich we stay abreast of new technologies and witness fire and flood performance tests on materials.

Allison Whittington is head of housing at Zurich Municipal

This feature first appeared in Public Property magazine. Email l.sharman@hgluk.com to sign up to your own free copy.

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

SEND Operations Assistant

Essex County Council
Up to £12.02 per hour
The SEND Operations Assistant provides administration and support to the statutory SEND processes such as the Annual Review Process, in particular at phase transfer, as well as providing a triage service for all contacts received by the SEND Operations Te England, Essex, Harlow
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Relief Resource Centre Worker - Nidderdale Children's Resource Centre - Award Winning Team

North Yorkshire County Council
£20,493
The role of Relief Resource Centre Worker is invaluable, rewarding, complex and challenging; you will play an... Harrogate, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire County Council

Specialist Teacher

Birmingham City Council
Main/ Upper Pay Scale + up to full SEN Allowance
This exciting opportunity will be to join a well-established team supporting children and young people with communication and... Birmingham, West Midlands
Recuriter: Birmingham City Council

People Analytics / Workforce Planning Lead

Essex County Council
Negotiable
Job Purpose This role will be responsible for carrying out data extraction, manipulation, research, analysis, and interpretation of data to provide me England, Essex, Chelmsford
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Building Surveyor

Royal Borough of Greenwich
£39774 - £42684 per annum + Essential Car Allowance
Hi All, I'm currently recruiting for this position. Please click on the job title below to view the Job Description and apply to it! England, London, Woolwich
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Public Property

Latest issue - Public Property News

This issue of Public Property examines how how flexible workspaces can lead the way in regeneration for local authorities, Why local authority intervention is key to successful urban regeneration schemes and if the Government’s challenge of embracing beauty is an opportunity for communities.

The March issue also takes a closer look at Blackburn with Darwen Council's first digital health hub to help people gain control over health and care services.

Register for your free digital issue