Jonathan Werran 04 April 2013

Councils in 'gag warfare'

Local government leaders have defended the use of compromise agreements as a cost-effective way of managing staff exits, following an attack by ministers on town hall 'gagging orders with big pay-offs'.

The comments came after Freedom of Information (FoI) campaigners revealed 256 English town halls brokered some 4,562 compromise agreements between 2005 and 2010.

Paul Carter and Katherine KerswellPaul Carter feels gagging orders are important in reducing the public cost of staff moves, as evidenced during Katherine Kerswell's split from Kent CC.

During this time Brighton and Hove City Council was the most prolific authority, signing 123 agreements – which often contain confidentiality clauses – to help staff leave their post.

Bristol City Council signed 121 agreements, Coventry City Council 114 and Bolton 107, according to Paul Cardin – a whistle-blowing former streetlighting employee of Wirral MBC, and latterly, at Cheshire West and Chester Council.

Research showed the average authority brokered 14 such exits, but 25 authorities didn’t issue any over this time period, Mr Cardin claimed.

Responding to the findings, communities secretary Eric Pickles – who in February wrote to councils stating all severance payments of £100,000 or more should be subject to a full vote at council meetings – criticised authorities for 'giving out thousands in under-the-counter pay-offs to silence departing staff'.

'For too long, local government has made departing staff sign gagging orders, often with big pay-offs attached, away from the eyes of those who get left with the bill: the taxpayer,' Mr Pickles said. Penny Thompson, chief executive of Brighton and Hove City Council, defended the use of severance packages. She said: 'Compromise agreements are used in some situations to cover the termination of an individual’s employment and can provide the most cost-effective route to resolving issues with the agreement of all parties.'

A spokesman for Bristol City Council claimed the historic FoI figures included deals struck by schools.Instead the spokesman confirmed 54 compromise agreements had been struck between the council and staff from 2008/09 to February 2013.

Mr Cardin's survey, which features on the 'Wirral in it together' blog, shows Kent CC negotiated 95 compromise agreements. However, one high-profile settlement, which falls outside the research's timescale, involved former managing director Katherine Kerswell – now director of civil service reform at the Cabinet Office.

Kent leader Cllr Paul Carter told The MJ that gagging orders help 'diminish the cost for the public purse' when making necessary staff moves. 'When we drew stumps on the contract with Katherine Kerswell we took the top QC's advice to make sure we didn't pay more than was reasonable,' Cllr Carter said.

According to Cllr Carter, it takes twice as long, and twice as much money, to remove staff by formal means when work situations are not working.

Richard Crouch, HR director at Somerset CC and vice president of the Public Sector People Managers' Association, agreed compromise agreements save council taxpayers large amounts of money.

'Without recourse to them, it's likely to lead to far more grievances, complaints and claims being lodged with tribunals,' added Mr Crouch.'The litigation costs in local authorities will go sky-high.'

A spokesperson for chief executives' union ALACE, said it is normal business practice for employers to negotiate financial compensation settlements with staff members who have done nothing wrong. She added: 'As the Secretary of State well knows, such payments are reported in the council's annual accounts. This is nothing to do with buying secrecy, and everything to do with professional business conduct.'

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Director of Legal and Governance (Monitoring Officer)

West Surrey Council
£141,891 - £156,080
Build the future, be the difference West Surrey
Recuriter: West Surrey Council

Children's Social Workers - Family Help Service

London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth
Up to £54,507 per annum (subject to experience) p