Mark Conrad 01 April 2009

‘Costly’ judicial reviews hit policies, says Healey

Extensive use of judicial reviews by councils is undermining policy-making and imposing unnecessary costs on taxpayers, John Healey has warned.
The local government minister told The MJ that too many councils were now launching legal reviews ‘simply to challenge government policies with which they do not agree’ – such as the introduction of new unitary authorities. Judicial reviews, he said, were introduced to assess the legality, not the appropriateness, of government policy.
Speaking to an audience of local government lawyers last week, Mr Healey said he regarded the judicial review process as ‘a vital cornerstone’ of democracy. But, he added: ‘If it is over-used or used for the wrong reasons – as a substitute for proper engagement in policy, for political point-scoring, or as a device to delay proper decision-making – it can have unintended consequences.’
The CLG spent £2.5m on litigation in 2007/08, but the bill for councils was far higher, because central government receives legal advice up to eight times cheaper than ‘commercial’ advice provided to town halls. Yet proposed judicial reviews are likely to fail.
In 2007, there were 6,690 review requests. Just 3% were permitted to go ahead and only half of them (114) were successful. The CLG faced nine reviews of its latest unitary proposals, but none were successful.
‘I ask whether we can justify spending taxpayers’ money on one part of government taking another part of government to court,’ Mr Healey said. ‘In many instances, the case itself is not sound or it’s a legal try-on to derail policy decisions because the challenging party disputes the policy intent.’
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Adults Social Worker - West Essex (Expression of Interest)

Essex County Council
£36124 - £51834 per annum + Flexible Working, Hybrid
Register your interest here to be notified of upcoming Social Worker opportunities within Essex County Council's Adult Social Care services in West E England, Essex, Harlow
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Director of Education

Nottingham City Council
£109,702 - £113,977 (Soulbury Grade 47 – 50)
We are now seeking visionary senior leaders to help shape the next phase of Nottingham's improvement journey. Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, Hybrid
Recuriter: Nottingham City Council

Senior Network Asset Inspector

Barnet London Borough Council
Salary range Grade J
Barnet London Borough Council
Recuriter: Barnet London Borough Council

Team Around the Family Worker

Nottinghamshire County Council
Starting Salary is £37,563 (Level one) rising to £40,444 (Level four) per annum (pro rata for part-time)
To work collaboratively with partners agencies to promote, implement, and embed the Team around the Family (TAF) Nottingham, Nottinghamshire
Recuriter: Nottinghamshire County Council

Occupational Therapy Assistant

Nottingham City Council
Starting Salary is £33,673 (Level one) rising to £36,581 (Level four) per annum (pro rata for part-time)
We're looking for a motivated and compassionate Occupational Therapy Assistant. NG11 8EW, Nottingham
Recuriter: Nottingham City Council
Linkedin Banner