William Eichler 29 July 2019

Campaigners call for reform of ‘broken’ electoral system

Campaigners call for reform of ‘broken’ electoral system image

Electoral reform campaigners have warned of a ‘crisis of legitimacy’ in local elections as research reveals the first-past-the-post system leads to widespread disproportionality.

In an analysis of the May local elections in England, the Electoral Reform Society (ERS) found that in 115 of the 248 councils holding elections, a party won more than 50% of the seats with less than 50% of the vote.

In the most extreme case, the ERS found that the Conservative Party took all of the seats up for election on Havant Council with just 43.9% of the vote.

This compares poorly with Scotland which has been using the Single Transferable Vote (STV) electoral system since 2004. In the Scottish local elections in 2017, no council saw a party get more than half the seats with less than half the first preference votes.

The ERS’ research also discovered that in 17 English councils this May, the party with the largest number of votes did not secure the most seats, creating ‘wrong winner’ results.

‘This research shows how our broken electoral system is distorting local election results,’ said Jess Garland, director of policy and research at the ERS.

‘First Past the Post is delivering skewed results in over a hundred councils across the country meaning many voters’ voices are unheard.

‘England continues to rely on this disproportionate system for local elections, where only the votes for the top candidate to ‘get over the line’ secure representation – all others are ignored. Spread out over thousands of contests, this can lead to some parties being drastically over- or under-represented.’

Dr Garland compared the English voting system to the STV system used in Scotland.

‘Since 2004, voters rank candidates by preference and “surplus” votes are redistributed according to voters’ choices. Most advanced democracies use proportional systems where seats more closely reflect parties’ share of the vote,’ she said.

‘It’s time we ended the broken first-past-the-post system in England – a system that continues to warp our politics. A more proportional system would help open local democracy and make sure all voters’ voices are heard.’

For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Head of HR/OD

Babergh & Mid Suffolk
£60,000 circa
The role will involve working closely with the Senior Leadership Team and Chief Executive to lead our People Strategy and... Ipswich, Suffolk
Recuriter: Babergh & Mid Suffolk

Customer Services Assistant (Libraries)

Essex County Council
Up to £9469 per annum
Please note this is part time position (18.5 hours a week) across Uttlesford, mainly based in Dunmow and Stansted and is to be offered on an initial 6 England, Essex, Dunmow
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Customer Services Assistant (Libraries)

Essex County Council
Up to £18938 per annum
Please note this position is to be offered on an initial 6 month , fixed term basis. Do you enjoy working with people? Enthusiastic about playing a ke England, Essex, Saffron Walden
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Customer Services Assistant - Mark Hall Library

Essex County Council
£17000 - £18950 per annum
Please note that this position is a part time role, offering 18.5 hours per week and is offered on a Fixed Term Basis for a period of 6 months. England, Essex, Harlow
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Senior Practitioner - Family Support & Protection

Essex County Council
Please note this is a fixed term contract or secondment opportunity until December 2020 In Essex County Council we are "Serious about Social Work". H England, Essex, Basildon
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Local Government News

Latest issue - Local Goverrnemnt News

This issue of Local Government News explores what impact the increase to the Public Works Loan Board rate have on councils’ capital schemes and why adopting AI will not just improve customer service response times for councils.

This issue also finds out how local government pension funds are backing infrastructure projects and calls on local government to get better value from its technology spend.

Register for your free magazine