David Fagan 20 August 2014

The future of strike action

David Cameron’s government has responded to recent public sectors strikes by promising to toughen up current strikes law in their 2015 election manifesto.

Trade unions, however, have argued that such an approach is discriminatory and unnecessary.

Under current regulations, for a strike to be authorised, unions must achieve a majority support of voters in a properly organised ballot while adhering to an extensive list of procedural requirements. Without this, an employer will have grounds to seek damages or an injunction to prevent strike action going ahead.

The conservative plans include a requirement that at least half of eligible union members must vote to secure a strike mandate and a 3 month time limit after the ballot for the strike action to take place, curtailing so called ‘rolling mandates’, which has seen walk-outs occur several months after the vote.

What does this mean for local government?

With the effect of austerity likely to be felt on local government finances well into the next Parliament the scope for further industrial action in the future seems high.

Many unions argue that legislation is restrictive enough already, and that new rules would make legitimate strikes ‘close to impossible’. A 50% threshold is likely to be out of reach in most cases and this could lead to challenge in the European Court of Human Rights.

If the proposals become law then the prospect of fewer days lost to industrial action will be welcome news to local government employers. However, if a successful strike ballot becomes more difficult to achieve there will be more emphasis on existing consultative and dispute resolution procedures. Local authorities and councils may look forward to spending even more time negotiating in future.

It is possible that acknowledging that a successful strike mandate will be unlikely might encourage more creative and engaged collaboration, but there must also be a risk that if negotiations break down and staff do not have the option of a strike employers might have to deal with an increasingly resentful and un-cooperative workforce.

At worst, tougher laws may result in an increased occurrence of unlawful strikes and the pay, disciplinary and other HR issues which inevitably accompany them.

Of course these measures will only be enacted if the Conservative Party succeeds at the next election. Even then many manifesto pledges fail to make it to the statute book. We will therefore have to wait to see whether these proposals are ever carried through.

David Fagan is employment partner at Weightmans LLP

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Financial Assessment Officer (Adult Social Care)

The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council
Negotiable
Shape outcomes across two leading London councils as a Financial Assessment Officer, delivering vital support that makes a real difference to residents' lives. England, London
Recuriter: The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council

No Wrong Door Team Manager – (Registered Children’s Home Manager)

North Yorkshire Council
£53,051 to £57,372 per annum
You will provide inspiring leadership, management and direction to staff, ensuring our culture, values and practice model Harrogate, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire Council

Occupational Therapist

The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council
Negotiable
Be part of a long-term complex occupational team that cares about patients and cares about you In Kensington and Chelsea, we support people's independence and wellbeing and work hard to enable them to live in the community with dignity, choice and cont England, London
Recuriter: The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council

Property Assistant

Durham County Council
£26,427 to £27,709 p.a. (Grade 4)
An opportunity has arisen within Corporate Property and Land for a part time, permanent Property Assistant based at Aycliffe Secure Centre in Newton A Newton Aycliffe
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Community Wellbeing Assistant

Durham County Council
£27,274 - £29,542
Temporary until March 2028  2 x 15 hours posts   Wellbing Sport and leisure are looking for 2 x 15 hours Wellbeing Assistant to join their team in th Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council
Linkedin Banner