Thomas Bridge 16 February 2015

'Shocking’ analysis reveals 500,000 five minute home care visits

Calls were today raised for a ‘fundamental’ overhaul of home care visits, after figures highlighted 500,000 appointments that lasted less than five minutes.

Results from Freedom of Information requests published in the Daily Telegraph suggest eight of England’s councils provided over 593,000 care visits to pensioners that lasted five minutes or less between 2010/11 and 2012/13.

The results came amid mounting Government pressure to crack down on ‘clock watch services’, which charities fear do not deliver suitable levels of care for vulnerable people.

Results suggest councils including Derbyshire, Dudley, Leicestershire, Milton Keynes and North Lincolnshire were among those who commissioned five-minutes visits.

Care minister Norman Lamb has now called for a ‘fundamental shift’ away from the practice, which he branded ‘totally inappropriate and unacceptable’.

‘It is just fanciful to think that elderly people can be provided with compassionate and kind care in this sort of timeslot,’ he added.

Derbyshire County Council said that use of ‘safe and well’ calls lasting five to 15 minutes were predominantly designed to remind people to take their medication and ‘not to provide personal care’. A spokesperson added that the recording system meant it was not possible to say whether visits were less than five minutes in length, as it included cases where residents were out when the visit was made.

A spokesman for Leicestershire County Council said: ‘The minimum call time for personal care we commission and pay for is 30 minutes and any visit can be extended by up to 50% if this is needed. Records of visits lasting five minutes or less represent only 0.6% of calls and are due to operator error in logging visits or because the person due to receive care may not be at home (e.g. taken into hospital).’

Cllr Dave Branwood, cabinet member for adult and community services at Dudley Council, said the calls referred to all occurred in a single sheltered housing scheme with on site staff, where employees deployed an ‘informal way of simply knocking the door to check people are safe and well’.

‘The five minutes in no way refers to the care they receive, and would be accompanied by a detailed package of care tailored to their needs. We find these brief visits help us to be more flexible in “checking in” on people and provide them with helpful regular visits from our carers. In other words this regular pattern of frequent visits is not to be confused with examples in the private sector were the care package its self may be concentrated into a five or 10 minute visit.’

Milton Keynes and North Lincolnshire similarly said short visits came as part of wider support packages and were accompanied by longer care visits on other occasions.

Andy Cole, director of corporate affairs at Leonard Cheshire Disability, said: ‘This new research is truly shocking. Visits of 15-minutes, or even as little as five-minutes, are totally unacceptable for delivering the sort of personal care that we would expect for ourselves or our loved ones.’

‘Council care budgets are facing almost impossible pressure – with resources shrinking and demand growing. We urgently need to see greater investment in care and support.’

The £37,000 SEND Problem image

The £37,000 SEND Problem

Natalie Kenneison, COO at Imosphere, argues that the real SEND funding crisis isn’t just about budgets - it’s about the systems behind the decisions.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Household Reviewing Officer

Essex County Council
£46574.0000 - £56027.0000 per annum
Household Reviewing OfficerPermanent, Part Time£46,574 to £56,027 per annum (FTE) (Full Time Equivalent) £27,944 to £33,616 per annum (Actual salary b England, Essex, Chelmsford
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Team Manager, Children and Families Hub

Essex County Council
£54001.0000 - £66899.0000 per annum
Team Manager, Children and Families HubPermanent, Full Time£54,001 to £66,899 Per AnnumLocation
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Senior Development Manager - Skills

South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority
£49,764 - £52,805
Our vision is for an economy which works for everyone, with inclusive and sustainable growth, building on our strengths... Sheffield, South Yorkshire
Recuriter: South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority

Contracts and Performance Manager

South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority
£49,764 - £52,805  
It is an exciting time to join the team as we work to deliver system change across work and health... Sheffield, South Yorkshire
Recuriter: South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority

Adults Social Worker - North Essex

Essex County Council
£37185 - £50081 per annum
Register your interest here to be notified for upcoming Social Worker opportunities within Essex County Council's Adult Social Care services in Nort England, Essex, Colchester
Recuriter: Essex County Council
Linkedin Banner