Ray Hart 29 January 2018

SEND/HNL provision in FE colleges: are we paying too much?

SEND/HNL provision in FE colleges: are we paying too much? image

With cost pressures dominating all areas of council spend, commissioners support for learners with SEND and HNL (Special Educational Needs & Disability/High Needs Learners) has come under scrutiny in recent years.

Significant inflationary pressures derived from wage rises and changes of central government support has also ensured that the rise in spend drives this topic to the top of many managers’ pain points.

With this in mind, commissioners have identified FE budgets as an area for review, conscious of the need to ensure value for money. With costs for similar support packages varying by up to 20% in the same area, many spending reviews have been undertaken by local authorities across the country.

The main motivation for commissioners to undertake reviews is to better understand why spend varies so significantly per learner and/or college and to ensure that inflationary increases are justified. Here’s an insight into how local authorities are ensuring value for money.

The process often begins with cost samples of various learners supported across a range of needs and a range of colleges. The aim of such a sample is to achieve a representative spread of underlying costs that mirrors the current market.

Generally, the learners sampled are those due to start college in the next academic year although some authorities also undertake reviews of current learners.

To aid the process further, FE colleges need to provide a breakdown of all areas of spend relating to the learner, including the core costs, specialist facilities and environments for SEND and HNL learners. This must include detail on any additional costs, for instance carers that relate to specific learners that are on top of the ‘standard’ costs.

Not all colleges are keen to fill out these type of templates but with commissioner’s support, it is often possible to gain enough data to make meaningful comparisons.

The main outcome from these surveys is the underlying differences of specific cost drivers, particularly staffing. As you would expect the cost of staff represents a significant proportion of each learner’s package.

The underlying costs of Learning Support Assistants (LSAs) highlights these differences well; LSAs can vary from £18,500 to £21,500, a difference of 16.2%. This level of difference can sometimes be explained by the skill set required by some colleges, but it is certainly something that local authorities should be mindful of, especially when specialist or higher LSAs command a premium.

To facilitate meaningful comparison, research into job advertisements for LSAs in the local area can also help. This provides a benchmark to compare costs with solely relying on the returns from the colleges.

In addition to the explained variation of spend through varied pay rates, reviews can highlight different accounting practices for salary on costs. Some of these practices significantly raise the price of the packages, with not all being justified. This is clearly an area that commissioners could consider when negotiating package prices.

Other areas of spend that vary significantly are the central overheads attributed to each learner. This varies depending on the size and underlying costs of the facilities on offer at a particular college. Here commissioners should consider what services is received for the spend, and whether this is value for money for the individuals involved. These costs may not be relevant to learners that have no need for additional facilitates.

The outcome of these type reviews for local authorities is that it offers a significant step forward in how commissioners negotiate new learner packages with colleges. Armed with the knowledge of both a specific college’s costs, and also the most cost effective colleges in the area, it is possible to negotiate better value for money package costs, with greater transparency.

In addition, areas that are not value for money or higher than average can provide commissioners with data to enter meaningful dialogue with specific colleges on how to remodel services to make them more cost effective in the medium to long term. This will ensure that local authority budgets are more sustainable, and colleges can be confident that they are doing all they can to achieve value for money, whilst supporting learners to achieve their best in their learning environment.

Ray Hart is director at Valuing Care.

Declaring a climate change emergency image

Declaring a climate change emergency

Local authorities can play a key role in tackling climate change – and there is plenty for them to do. Never before has thinking globally and acting locally been more important, says Mark Whitehead.
Highways jobs

Senior Practitioner - Family Support and Protection

Essex County Council
£28500.0 - £50400.0 per annum
In Essex County Council we are "Serious about Social Work". Having recently won the Best Social Work Employer of the Year Award 2018 and been awarded England, Essex, Basildon
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Team Manager

Suffolk County Council
£39,723 - £49,385
South Team, Learning Disability and Autism Service, Adult and Community Services. Suffolk
Recuriter: Suffolk County Council

Social Worker - Family Support & Protection

Essex County Council
£30001.0 - £41000.0 per annum
Please note this role is based in Basildon and is open to Newly Qualified Social Workers (NQSWs). The starting salary for NQSWs is £27,500 per annum a England, Essex, Basildon
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Social Worker -Mental Health Team

Essex County Council
£22700.0 - £40750.0 per annum
Social Worker Adults Mental HealthEssex County Council (ECC) is one of the largest and most dynamic local authorities in the UK, serving a population England, Essex, Basildon
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Claims Investigation Officer

Royal Borough of Greenwich
£36,711 - £39,774
An exciting opportunity has arisen for an experienced Claims Handler Greenwich, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Local Government News

Latest issue - Local Goverrnemnt News

The June issue of Local Government News contains the full details of all the winning schemes in the 2019 Street Design Awards. From Children's Play to Pedestrian Environment, find out who has been recognised for their innovation and use of best practice.

This issue also explores how local government pension funds can hedge currency risk, how councils can best address the shortfall in school places, and an update on the number of authorities banning the use of Roundup over safety fears.

Register for your free magazine