Tiffany Cloynes 30 April 2018

Local authority elections - publicity and decision making

With local authorities in England preparing for the local government elections on 3 May, including some with mayoral elections, it is a good time to remind ourselves of some of the legal and practical issues relating to publicity and decision making that may affect local authorities at a time of elections.

Publicity

Local authorities are prohibited from publishing or arranging the publication of information which appears to be designed to affect support for a political party and from providing financial or other assistance to a person for the publication of information which the local authority itself would be prohibited from publishing.

As well as complying with this prohibition, they must have regard to the Code of Recommended Practice on Local Authority Publicity issued by the secretary of state for communities and local government for local authorities in England.

The Code is relevant to local authority publicity at all times but it identifies the pre-election period as a period of heightened sensitivity and advises particular caution at such a time. The Code says that in the period between notice of an election and the election itself, local authorities should not publish publicity on controversial issues or report proposals in such a way that it identifies them with any individual members or groups of members.

Local authorities should not during that period publish publicity relating to individuals who are involved directly in the election unless this is expressly authorised by or under statute. The Code also says that local authorities may need to suspend hosting material produced by third parties or to close public forums to avoid breaching any legal restrictions

'Publicity' is defined for the purposes of Part II of the Local Government Act 1986 as referring to any communication, in whatever form, addressed to the public at large or to a section of the public. This means that the statutory requirements and the Code could apply to a wide range of publicity.

Decisions

There may be particular sensitivity associated with decisions taken near to the time of elections. Those authorities with elections will generally organise their meetings and other arrangements in such a way that decision makers are not required to decide on controversial matters during this time. However, local authorities need to be able to go about their usual business and discharge their functions, so some decisions will need to be made.

As well as the risk of breaching the statutory requirements or the Code through publicity about controversial decisions, local authorities should be alert to the risk of decisions being affected by predetermination. In order to take a lawful decision, a local authority’s decision makers need to approach each decision with an open mind. If members express strong opinions on matters – and they may feel particularly inclined to do so when the parties they represent campaign on particular issues prior to an election – and are later required to take decisions relating to those matters, it is important that they do not provide grounds to suggest that they approach the decisions with closed minds. An indication of initial thoughts is acceptable but predetermination would make a local authority’s decision unlawful.

After many cases considered the question of predetermination, the UK Government sought to clarify the position by introducing section 25 of the Localism Act 2011. This takes the position that a decision maker will not be regarded as having predetermined an issue simply by indicating what view he or she might take. This is of some help but if a local authority member actually were to approach a decision with predetermination, that decision could be found to be invalid. Therefore, notwithstanding section 25 of the Localism Act 2011, it will be important for decision-makers to be able to show that they approach each decision with an open mind.

Local authorities will need to be alert to the risk of predetermination or appearance of predetermination when comments are made at periods of sensitivity.

Whilst the immediate priority of local authorities with elections will understandably be on managing the elections themselves, it is important that they give some attention to these wider issues, in order to avoid any challenges to their decisions and actions.

Tiffany Cloynes is partner and head of the regeneration and public services team in England at Geldards LLP

LGOF: Will it work? image

LGOF: Will it work?

Dr Jonathan Carr-West, LGIU, discusses the Local Government Outcomes Framework (LGOF), the latest instalment in the history of local government accountability.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Family Support Worker

Durham County Council
Grade 6 - £27,269 - £30,060 (Pay award pending)
Do you have a real passion for helping families to make positive changes for themselves and their children? This might be the right role for you!   WH Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Clerical Officer Receptionist

Durham County Council
Grade 3 £24,404 - £25,183 Pro Rata to hours worked Pay award pending
WHAT IS INVOLVED? We are looking to appoint a part time Clerical officer/Receptionist within Business Services to provide a professional, effective a Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Administration Assistant

Durham County Council
£25,584 - £27,711 pro rata
Administration Assistant Grade 5    £25,584 - £27,711 pro rata Temporary – required from 1st October 2025 until 31 December 2025 37 hours per week, Te Consett
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Support Assistant

Durham County Council
£24,027 pro rata
Support Assistant Grade 1 £24,027 pro rata Temporary – required from 1st October 2025 until 31st October 2026 Part Time, 32.5 hours Mon - Fri 9am -4pm Consett
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Lecturer in Foundation Learning -Maths, English and Digital

Durham County Council
Grade 9 £34,314 - £37,938 pro rata for part-time term time working PAY AWARD PENDING
The DurhamLearn Foundation Learning programme area delivers Digital Skills, English and Maths Functional Skills.   An opportunity has arisen for a Lec Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council
Linkedin Banner