William Eichler 23 August 2016

Digital transformation has been mostly ‘cosmetic’, study finds

Public sector digital transformation initiatives have been mostly ‘cosmetic’ and have not delivered in terms of outcomes or return on investment, Brunel University research reveals.

Brunel’s study argued the potential of ICT to change policy design, implementation and administrative practice has been ‘missed’. ‘Digital’, they said, should be enabling transformative policy development ‘rather than just doing existing policies faster, better, and cheaper.’

Socitm acknowledges Brunel’s conclusions and outlines what it describes as the three key ‘delusions’ identified in current approaches to deploying digital technology in government and public administration.

The first ‘delusion’ is that digital transformation is about cutting costs. In fact, Socitm points out, it raises the need for additional resources for development, maintenance, security and redesign for new channels.

The second ‘delusion’ is everything has to be user-focused. Local authorities who focus solely on the interface overlook real transformation of government processes.

The final ‘delusion’ highlighted by Socitm is that technology alone transforms processes. Government and public administration are rooted in nations’ constitutions, in policy and in law, and consequently much more than technology is needed to rationalise them.

According to Socitm, organisations that take the simplify, standardise and share approach - laid out by the Local Public Services CIO Council (LCIOC) in collaboration with Socitm and SOLACE - can avoid these ‘delusions of transformation’.

‘Socitm and LCIOC are actively pursuing this approach in our contributions to developing plans and actions for health and social care integration and for cybersecurity and resilience,’ said Martin Ferguson, head of policy at Socitm.

‘The Brunel critique of past e-government and current digital transformation programmes is timely and thoughtful, challenging us to reserve the term “transformation” only for when it is fully justified.’

Read our feature asking if a more more standardised, digital approach could improve the delivery of local government services.

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Family Support Worker

Durham County Council
Grade 6 £27,269 - £30,060 (Pay Award Pending)
Do you want to work in an ambitious Local Authority with strong leadership and partnership commitment to Children’s Services? Durham County Council a Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

SENDIASS Support Officer

Durham County Council
Grade 8 £31,586 - £35,235 (Pay Award Pending)
An exciting and rewarding opportunity has arisen within the busy and fast paced SEND Information, Advice, Support Service (SENDIASS). The service has Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Residential Worker

Durham County Council
Grade 7 £29,093 - £32,654 (Pay Award Pending)
Salary
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Team Leader

Durham County Council
Grade 8 £31,586 - £35,235 (Pay Award Pending)
Salary
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Class Teacher

Durham County Council
£31,650- £33,483
Class Teacher MPS 1 -2   £31,650- £33,483 Temporary – required from Monday 1st September 2025 (subject to DBS) until 31st August 2026 25 hours per wee Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council
Linkedin Banner