Mark Whitehead 17 January 2018

Devolution - have the wheels fallen off the wagon?

For a time devolution was all the rage in local government circles. Councils lined up to announce they were joining forces and taking advantage of new decentralised powers handed down by Whitehall, extra funding and the right to elect their own mayors.

But all that seems to have come to a grinding halt. Last week a government report - snuck out 10 months after it was written - revealed there had been no new devolution plans agreed last year. Suddenly the wheels seem to have fallen off the devolution wagon.

The inspiration behind the great devolution reform was bold. Announcing his plans in October 2015, then chancellor George Osborne said devolving powers to local areas would promote growth and prosperity. Local government would be able to retain 100% of local taxes, including business rates, to spend on services.

It was the dawn of a new era, but it followed the failure of more ambitious plans for regional government when people in the North East of England firmly rejected the opportunity to create their own assembly in a poll in 2004.

Instead, reflecting the trend for decentralising which had seen power devolved to new governments in Scotland and Wales, the idea of localities based on city regions gained currency.

The Government saw the advantages of councils joining forces and the idea of the combined authority with their own mayors emerged - seized first by Greater Manchester.

Local government leaders have strongly supported the trend. Devolution, according to the Local Government Association, is 'one of the most fundamental changes to the way decisions are made for local areas and how public services are funded,' providing 'greater freedoms and flexibilities at a local level, meaning councils can work more effectively to improve public services for their area,' and providing 'more effective, better targeted public services, greater growth and stronger partnerships between public, private and community leaders in local areas.'

So far, in the areas which have taken advantage of it, devolution appears to be successful and few would argue with the principle of people having more say over what happens in the localities where they live and work.

But local decision-making means greater responsibility and the biggest councils are clearly best placed to take it on - hence it is the big cities, in the main, which have been first to take advantage of the new freedoms.

Smaller councils, though, may not have the resources - or the inclination - to take on the extra responsibility.

There is also a paradox at the heart of the devolution agenda: when several councils combine forces they gain powers from central government, but by combining, each inevitably loses some of its independence, historically a treasured principle of local government. And adding a mayor to the formula creates a separate seat of power, meaning traditional councils, again, lose a little piece of their prized sovereignty.

The government's favoured method of promoting change, by asking for proposals to be submitted, inevitably leads to big differences in what devolution actually means in practice. The idea of councils offering similar services to residents and businesses throughout the country is being replaced by a patchwork of different settlements from one place to another. There has always been inconsistency between councils, but giving them more freedom, it can be argued, is likely to increase it.

There are more prosaic reasons for the current pause. The government has had its hands full with major events including the EU referendum, the Grenfell disaster and the general election, and seems to have been less concerned with local government reform.

The LGA's response to the current 'deadlock' is to call for more government encouragement to councils which have so far failed to grasp the devolution option.

Cllr Mark Hawthorne, chairman of the LGA’s people and places board, said more deals were needed to allow communities across the country to benefit, calling on the government to 'jump-start the devolution debate'.

'There is now a real risk that areas without devolution deals will be left behind,' he warned. 'This risks undermining the government’s ambition to bring prosperity and productivity to all parts of the country.'

Whether more councils will respond to such calls remains to be seen. Perhaps the future local government landscape will include big, successful combined authorities with high-profile mayors alongside traditional councils continuing as before.

There may be more deals in the year ahead, and it remains to be seen whether the wheels have actually fallen off the devolution wagon and the new era ushered in by George Osborne has come to an end - or just put on pause for the moment.

For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Assistant Highways Officer

Lincolnshire County Council
£21,269 - £23,953
Lincolnshire County Council is looking to recruit an Assistant Highways Officer Lincoln, Lincolnshire
Recuriter: Lincolnshire County Council

Highways Officer

Lincolnshire County Council
£26,466 - £29,174
Lincolnshire County Council is looking to appoint a Highways Lincolnshire
Recuriter: Lincolnshire County Council

Social Worker - Children in Care

Essex County Council
£32787 - £44826 per annum + + Free On-Site Parking & Benefits Package
Closing Date
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Newly Qualified Social Workers - Children in Care

Essex County Council
£32787 - £44826 per annum + + Free On-Site Parking & Benefits Package
These positions are open to Newly Qualified Social Workers (NQSW's) and Experienced Social Workers. The starting salary for a NQSW is £29,236 per a England, Essex, Basildon
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Assistant Project Manager

Essex County Council
£31200 - £36763 per annum
Assistant Project ManagerFixed Term, 12 monthsFull Time, 37 hours per weekUp to £36,763 per annumLocation
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Partner Content

Circular highways is a necessity not an aspiration – and it’s within our grasp

Shell is helping power the journey towards a circular paving industry with Shell Bitumen LT R, a new product for roads that uses plastics destined for landfill as part of the additives to make the bitumen.

Support from Effective Energy Group for Local Authorities to Deliver £430m Sustainable Warmth Funded Energy Efficiency Projects

Effective Energy Group is now offering its support to the 40 Local Authorities who have received a share of the £430m to deliver their projects on the ground by surveying properties and installing measures.

Pay.UK – the next step in Bacs’ evolution

Dougie Belmore explains how one of the main interfaces between you and Bacs is about to change.