Thomas Bridge 21 February 2014

Court upholds lawful ruling on 'bedroom tax'

Five disabled housing tenants have failed in their bid to have the 'bedroom tax' deemed unlawful in the Court of Appeal.

The court upheld last year's High Court ruling that the Government's spare room subsidy - which reduces housing benefit for those deemed to be under-occupying their council property - is not unlawfully discriminatory.

Lawyers argued regulations introduced in April did not take into account the accommodation requirements of disabled residents.

Claims were also turned out from two lone parents, who had argued the 'bedroom tax' violates human rights laws and common law because of its impact on vulnerable families.

Original challenges to the Government policy came from 10 families in July last year. Since then, five cases involving disabled children are no longer being pursued because these families have come under exemptions.

Responding to the judgement, a Department for Work and Pensions spokesperson said: 'We are pleased that the courts have once again found in our favour and agreed this policy is lawful.

'Reform of housing benefit in the social sector is essential to ensure the long-term sustainability of the benefit. But we have ensured extra discretionary housing support is available for vulnerable people.'

Ugo Hayter from law firm Leigh Day, one of the law firms representing two people in the legal challenge, said: 'We are extremely disappointed by this judgment and we are baffled by the findings of the Court of Appeal.

'The court recognised that our clients and thousands of disabled people across the UK had a need for accommodation not provided for by the new housing benefit rules, however the court decided that disabled tenants should not have their housing needs met on an equivalent basis to their able-bodied counterparts, just because they are disabled.'

SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Senior/Principal Regeneration Officer

Fareham Borough Council
£45,465 - £55,379
Our town centre regeneration is moving from planning to delivery, and we're looking for someone who wants to help make regeneration happen. Fareham, Hampshire
Recuriter: Fareham Borough Council

Director of Law & Corporate Governance (Monitoring Officer)

Northumberland County Council
£ 143,779 - £158,197
With the forthcoming retirement of our current postholder, we are seeking an outstanding leader Northumberland
Recuriter: Northumberland County Council

Assistant Director of Finance (DS151)

Rochdale BC
£82,028 - £94,797 + £7,000 responsibilities allowance
This is an influential role, offering the opportunity to lead established teams across finance, revenues and benefits, internal audit Rochdale, Greater Manchester
Recuriter: Rochdale BC

Head of Economic Development

Redbridge London Borough Council
£91,977 - £95,592
We’re looking for somebody who can build local and regional networks and foster positive relationships London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Head of Leisure & Culture

Redbridge London Borough Council
£103,263 - £107,322
A major part of the role is fulfilling the role of ‘client’ in relation to our outsourced Leisure and Culture provision London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council
Linkedin Banner