William Eichler 07 June 2017

Council pays out £2000 after blind woman unable to vote

A woman has won a legal challenge against her district council over voting access for the blind and partially sighted.

Rachael Andrews, 44, Norwich, has myopic macular degeneration and is registered blind. She attended her local polling station on 7 May 2015 to vote in the general and local elections but had to do it through a third party due to inadequate facilities.

The Representation of the People Act 1983 states that polling stations must be equipped with a device that enables blind and partially sighted people to vote without assistance.

However, the current device used to meet these requirements -- the Tactile Voting Device (‘TVD’) – was not available to Ms Andrews and her husband, who is also blind, and the presiding officer had never heard of one.

Ms Andrews' mother-in-law had to read out the candidate names to her and then had to mark her votes on her ballot papers on her behalf. This compromised her statutory duty, right to vote in secret, and right to vote independently.

After complaining about the incident to Broadland District Council – and chasing on several occasions – Ms Andrews did not receive a satisfactory response.

The case went to court and was settled for £2000, an apology and recognistion of discrimination from the council, and assurances improvements would be made.

‘I felt that the polling station staff didn’t care that I would not be able to cast my vote independently – I felt like I didn’t exist and that my vote counted less than everyone else’s,’ said Ms Andrews.

‘The fact that I had to chase for a response and resort to legal action to seek redress added to my feelings that my complaint and my inability to vote in private was not taken seriously by my local authority.’

Commenting on the case, Kate Egerton from the human rights team at the law firm Leigh Day said: ‘Our client said she was made to feel like a child having to press the presiding officer to provide her with a TVD, have the candidates read aloud to her, state who she intended to vote for in front of everyone in the polling station, and then have her mother-in-law cast her vote for her, which was degrading and disempowering.’

In response the council said: 'Broadland District Council has apologised to Mrs Andrews in relation to her voting experience during the 2015 General Election and as a result we have improved our voting systems for all our visually impaired residents.

'On the occasions that Mrs Andrews has voted since, we have liaised closely with Mrs Andrews to support her to vote more confidently and independently.'

Black hole spending review image

Black hole spending review

Jonathan Werran, chief executive of Localis, reflects on what the Spending Review means for local government.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Community Transport Co-Ordinator - Braintree District Council

Essex County Council
£13.5700 - £14.9500 per hour
Community Transport Co-ordinator - Braintree District Council Temporary, Full Time£13.57 - £14.95 per HourBraintree, EssexClosing Date
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Procurement Manager

Essex County Council
£46388.0000 - £54573.0000 per annum
Procurement ManagerPermanent, Full Time£46,388 to £54,573 per annumLocation
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Youth Officer (CDC)

City Of Doncaster Council
Grade 7, £27,259 - £29,955 (Pay award pending)
The City of Doncaster Council is a confident, ambitious organisation Doncaster, South Yorkshire
Recuriter: City Of Doncaster Council

Social Worker - Assessment & Intervention Mid Essex

Essex County Council
£37185.0000 - £50081.0000 per annum
Social Worker - Assessment & Intervention Mid EssexPermanent, Full Time£37,185 to £50,081 per annum Location
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Director – Housing Services

Redbridge London Borough Council
£Competitive
Are you ready to lead transformative housing services in one of London’s most ambitious and diverse boroughs? Redbridge, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council
Linkedin Banner