Hiba Mahamadi 04 December 2019

Councils could lose millions in utilities repayments after court ruling

Local authorities could be facing repayments worth millions of pounds to council tenants in excess water charges, after a High Court ruling last week.

The court found Kingston upon Thames RLBC unlawfully over-charged a council tenant for water between 2003 and 2017.

During this period, the authority collected payments for water and sewerage services from its tenants for Thames Water Utilities. But the water company had offered the council a discount on the overall bill payable: 3.5% off the total charges, plus 9.3% off the remaining sum payable. This meant Kingston was paying a reduced sum of money for water bills over this period. 

The tenant, Derek Moss, argued this discount was not reflected in the council’s water bill to tenants. He added the council should only charge him for the water he used as per his tenancy agreement and return the discounted sum. 

The High Court ruled in favour of Mr Moss, noting he has the right to be reimbursed for the extra money paid to the council over the years.

Mr Justice Morgan wrote: “Mr Moss has a right to recover overpayments of charges pursuant to section 150(5) of the 1991 Act and paragraph 10(1) of the Water Resale Order 2006…

“Mr Moss has overpaid the charges which were due under the revised terms of his tenancy agreement”.

The judgement comes after a similar resolution against Southwark LBC in 2016, in which the council was held liable to repay a tenant for excess water charges.

Southwark calculated its tenants had made overpayments worth £28.6m.

The law firm, Deighton Pierce Glynn (DPG), that represented the tenants against Kingston RLBC and Southwark LBC, has said the ruling could see many more council tenants make claims for extra water charges.

A DPG statement read: 'The impact of today’s result could be felt in millions of pounds of refunds to council tenants in Kingston and many other local authority areas.'

DPG solicitor Daniel Carey added the ruling reiterated local authorities’ duty to pass on any discounts negotiated with water companies to tenants.

A spokesman for Kingston upon Thames RLBC said: 'We are considering the outcome with our legal representatives.'

What’s happening inside the LGPS? image

What’s happening inside the LGPS?

Get the most informed take on the challenges and opportunities that substantial reform will bring at this year’s PLSA Local Authority Conference.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

KS2 Class Teacher

Durham County Council
£31,650 - £43,607
KS2 Class Teacher   M1 – M6     £31,650 - £43,607 Full Time, Whole Time Temporary – required from 1st September 2025 until 31st August 2026  The head Bowburn
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Deputy Manager, Children’s Homes Service

Durham County Council
Grade 11 £39,513 - £43,693
The Role We are seeking Deputy Managers who will support the Registered Manager to ensure the delivery of high-quality care. You will work directly wi Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Independent Reviewing Officer

Durham County Council
Grade 14 £48,710 - £52,805 pro rata
Are you a child and family social worker with 5 years of post-qualifying experience looking for the next step of your career?   What is Involved? As a Spennymoor
Recuriter: Durham County Council

Class Teacher

Durham County Council
£31,650 - £43,607
Class Teacher M1-M6  £31,650 - £43,607 Full time, whole time Temporary – required from 2nd September 2025 until August 2026 The governors of Escomb P Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council

School Crossing Patrol

Durham County Council
Grade 1 £3,968 (approx.) £12.45 per hour
Join our School Crossing Patrol Service! Are you punctual and reliable? Do you have good communication skills and a strong sense of community spirit? Durham
Recuriter: Durham County Council
Linkedin Banner