Mark Whitehead 19 October 2017

Council liable for foster care abuse, judge rules

Local authorities could face a big increase in claims by foster children over historic or recent child abuse after a landmark ruling by the Supreme Court.

Lawyers warned councils may now have to award foster parents holiday and sick pay as the ruling meant they could now be classed as 'workers'.

Former foster child Natasha Armes from Nottingham won her case against Nottinghamshire County Council after judges ruled it was liable for abuse she suffered as a child 30 years ago.

They found that even though the council was not negligent in choosing or supervising the foster parents, it was 'vicariously liable' for the physical and sexual abuse they committed.

The ruling overturned previous decisions against Ms Armes at the High Court and Court of Appeal.

In the judgment Lord Reed said the local authority carried out the recruitment, selection and training of foster parents, paid their expenses and supervised the fostering.

The 'foster parents with which the present case is concerned cannot be regarded as carrying on an independent business of their own', he said.

'Although the picture presented is not without complexity, nevertheless when considered as a whole it points toward the conclusion that the foster parents provided care to the child as an integral part of the local authority's organisation of its child care services.'

Ms Armes' lawyers said the judgment had 'finally put right a terrible injustice which has denied so many victims a legal redress that is widely available to other survivors of abuse.'

They added: 'This removes the arbitrary distinction which meant local authorities could be held vicariously liable for abuse if it took place in a children's home, but not if it took place in a foster carer's home.'

The judges said the next stage of the litigation was for damages to be assessed.

Colin Pettigrew, corporate director for children and families at Nottinghamshire County Council, said: 'Ms Armes should have been safe in the care of her foster carers 30 years ago and she wasn’t, this is a matter of huge regret to us.

'We, of course, accept the findings of the Supreme Court and will be working with Ms Armes' representatives to resolve any outstanding issues related to our liability.

'This Supreme Court determination will have far-reaching implications for us and every other local authority across the land which has children’s social care responsibilities.'

Will devolution deepen the UKs social divide? image

Will devolution deepen the UK's social divide?

As the UK Government advances its devolution agenda, shifting power from Westminster to new regional authorities, it’s fair to ask what it means for diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), says Gita Singham-Willis, Strategic Engagement Director at Transform UK.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Community Learning and Skills Tutor (Accredited Courses) WMF2630e

Westmorland and Furness Council
36,363.00 to 37,280.00 pro rata
Do you want to inspire learners in your community? Workington, Cumbria
Recuriter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Project Manager - Transformation Programme WMF2607e

Westmorland and Furness Council
£45,091 - £46,142
This is not just another project management role—it’s your chance to shape the future of services for our residents. Cumbria / Various
Recuriter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Social Worker - Children we Care for

Oxfordshire County Council
38220 - 45091
We’ve transformed the way we help our social workers get the best outcomes possible for every child and family we work with. We do this through manageable caseloads, great management support, reflective supervision, continual professional development i Oxfordshire
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

Driver Technician - WMF2632e

Westmorland and Furness Council
£26,403- £26,824
This is an exciting opportunity for skilled Drivers to join our Community Equipment Service Ulverston, Cumbria
Recuriter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Adults Social Worker - Older Adults Mental Health

Essex County Council
£37185 - £50081 per annum
Interviews will be held in person at Rowan House, Colchester on 27th February 2026.This position is open to Experienced and Newly Qualified Social Wo England, Essex, Colchester
Recuriter: Essex County Council
Linkedin Banner