29 November 2010

Auditors slam 'poor value' M25 deal

The National Audit Office (NAO) has criticised the Highway's Agency PFI deal to widen the M25 for being too expensive and too slow to implement.

In a new report, the NAO said the multibillion-pound deal could have been better value for money, and added that the Highway's Agency was too slow investigating cheaper alternatives to the road-widening project. The report estimates the NAO could have saved between £400m and £1.1bn from a conventionally-procured hard shoulder scheme. It also notes the agency is now using hard-shoulder running on a number of other major roads. 'The agency should have adopted a more agile approach to procurement,' said NAO head, Amyas Morse.

The chair of the public accounts committee, Margaret Hodge, said she could see 'many familiar problems' in the report. 'Both I and my colleagues will have some tough questions for the Highways Agency when it comes before us in a few weeks time.' A spokesman for the Highways Agency said it would respond to the report at the select committee hearing next month.

RAC Foundation director, Professor Stephen Glaister, called for more long-term planning regarding motorway widening and hard-shoulder running. The Campaign for Better Transport's road campaigner, Richard George, told Surveyor it was 'madness' the Highways Agency did not look at all the options properly. 'Alarm bells should have been ringing when it saw the cost of the scheme,' he added.

He said the Government was likely to make the same mistake with the forthcoming Mersey Gateway PFI deal, which he described as 'unaffordable'. Mr George added that hard shoulder running was 40% cheaper than widening motorways, and had proved popular with drivers during a recent trial on the M42 in Birmingham.

LGOF: Will it work? image

LGOF: Will it work?

Dr Jonathan Carr-West, LGIU, discusses the Local Government Outcomes Framework (LGOF), the latest instalment in the history of local government accountability.
SIGN UP
For your free daily news bulletin
Highways jobs

Lawyer 1 - Litigation

Herefordshire Council
£39,513 - £43,693
We are looking for a fresh thinking and enthusiastic Litigation Lawyer to join our dedicated and friendly Litigation Team within Legal Services. Hereford, Herefordshire
Recuriter: Herefordshire Council

Part Time Senior Accountant (Job Share)

Ribble Valley Borough Council
PO6-9 (scp 36-39) £45,718 to £48,710 per annum pro rata
An exciting opportunity has arisen in the role of Senior Accountant. Clitheroe, Lancashire
Recuriter: Ribble Valley Borough Council

Purchase to Pay Administrator (Fixed Term) - WMF2122e

Westmorland and Furness Council
£25,584 - £25,992
There is an expectation that the post-holder will work from the Carlisle office for training on a regular basis. Cumbria / Various
Recuriter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Social Worker - WMF2123e

Westmorland and Furness Council
£41,511 - £42,708
We’re looking for passionate social workers to join our team in Kendal following a recent reshape of our services. Kendal, Cumbria
Recuriter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Grants Support Officer

Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council
Band D, SCP 9 -17 (£26,409 - £30,060 per annum)
Are you passionate about making a difference to people’s lives and communities in Sandwell? Sandwell, West Midlands
Recuriter: Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council
Linkedin Banner