William Eichler 12 October 2018

Southern councils criticise ‘misleading’ funding claims

Southern councils criticise ‘misleading’ funding claims image

Local authorities in the south of England have hit back against a Cambridge University analysis of local government funding that suggested southern councils had experienced ‘relatively minor’ service cuts.

Analysis in the university’s study The depth of the cuts was ‘misleading’ and served only to ‘pit councils against each other,’ according to South East England Councils (SEEC) and South East Strategic Leaders (SESL).

The study found that councils in England had suffered an average service spending fall of almost 24% since 2010, compared to 12% in Wales and 11.5% in Scotland.

All 46 councils that reduced spending by 30% or more are located in England, with the deepest cuts in the north, according to The depth of the cuts. Southern England, meanwhile, had experienced ‘relatively minor’ service cuts.

In response, a statement from SEEC and SESL has said that the report ‘misleads readers’ because it fails to look at how much grant each area receives and whether that amount matches a council’s needs.

This leaves readers with the impression that the highest cuts have led to the lowest spending on local services, a fact spokespeople for SEEC and SESL argue is ‘far from the situation.’

In the South East, for example, percentage cuts of 19% from 2009-10 to 2016-17 left councils spending an average £628 per person on local services, while in London percentage cuts were higher at 39% but the average spend per person also remained higher at £861.

‘This sort of misleading analysis simply serves to pit councils against each other,’ said Cllr Martin Tett chairman of SESL.

‘At the moment councils across the country are 'running on empty'. Many councils in the South East now receive no Government revenue funding whatsoever and have faced the prospect of 'negative RSG', in practice taking away local raised revenue.

‘Counties and unitaries in the South East face some of the greatest demographic pressures, particularly for adult social care and the highest level of costs. 

‘It is important for all councils that the Government resolves financial uncertainties quickly and confirms fair financial settlements for the coming years.’

Cllr Tett added that as leader of Buckinghamshire CC he did not ‘recognise the report's description of “relatively minor” service cuts.’

‘We have had to make major savings of hundreds of millions of pounds, with big reductions in virtually all services including parks, libraries, social care, community services, education and road maintenance,’ he said.

In competition with the PWLB image

In competition with the PWLB

Christian Wall considers what alternative funding channels are available to local authorities beyond the Public Works Loan Board.
Avoiding the precipice image

Avoiding the precipice

As councils seek ways to meet the funding gap, Martin Reeves and Rob Whiteman look at the implications for the future of public services and how we need a mature debate on prevention, accountability and joined up services.
Highways jobs

Change Lead, Adult Social Care & Health

London Borough of Bexley
£41,205 - £48,069
We are currently seeking an experienced Change Lead to work on our Adult Social Care Services’ transformation programme. Bexleyheath, London (Greater)
Recuriter: London Borough of Bexley

Deputy Team Manager

Brent Council
£41,847 - £44,691 p.a. inc.
An exciting opportunity has arisen in the Hospital Discharge Team (HDT) for an experienced Social Worker. Wembley, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Brent Council

Highways Estimator

Ringway
Competitive Salary
As the Highways Estimator you will join a busy environment and become an integral part of the team. Hounslow (London Borough), London (Greater)
Recuriter: Ringway

Joint Strategic Director of Commissioning 

West Sussex County Council
circa £130,000 per annum
The post holder will be able to demonstrate an understanding and embrace the opportunity to address the health... West Sussex
Recuriter: West Sussex County Council

Head of Lifelong Services

West Sussex County Council
up to £85,000 per annum
The Head of Lifelong Services will lead and deliver a new, co-produced, integrated and whole life approach and service working with people... West Sussex
Recuriter: West Sussex County Council

Local Government News

Latest issue - Local Goverrnemnt News

The December issue of Local Government News looks at the consequences a council may face if it is unable to provide statutory services, the launch of Liverpool’s housing company and how councils can best manage roles in local authority companies.

It also has a special section on green building and energy efficiency including what funding is available to enable councils to deliver heat networks and how councils can pay for ‘smart buildings’.

Register for your free magazine